The Notre Dame hype machine is on a roll...
Anyway, just to nip this AP argument. Big XII defense still wasn't good that year, even though it wasn't a "spread" conference yet. Plus, that year Oklahoma skated, the only top defense that Oklahoma played was Texas (Based on total D) and Texas was ranked 23. They also played another top D and that was USC (#6) in the title game and we all know the result. Top D's in the Big XII that year were Wisconsin (#9), Oklahoma (#13) and Mizzou (#14), and OU didn't play Wisconsin or Mizzou.
USC faced three top 25 defenses that year: Virginia Tech (#4), Oregon State (#1
and Cal (#24).
Carson Palmer,
What Peterson did as a freshman was remarkable, however, one can argue JJ Arrington and DeAngelo Williams balled just as hard as AP that year. Can't scream robbery when you weren't even the best back that year, it's debatable.