The Invincible Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I see dudes don't know about B Mitch. Learn your NFL history folks. Mitchell has almost 10,000 more return yards then Hester kick and punt. How is this even debatable?
 
I see dudes don't know about B Mitch. Learn your NFL history folks. Mitchell has almost 10,000 more return yards then Hester kick and punt. How is this even debatable?

Maybe because he played 80 more football games? And in an era where they didn't create rules to limit kickoff returns?

Hester has more TD's than Mitch in 4 less seasons. How is this even debatable? :wink:


Hester averaged more yards per Punt Return, AND more yards per Kick Return.

Mitchell just has hundreds more returns to his name is all.
 
Last edited:
brian Mitchell is probably the only thing skins and eagles can agree upon..

unless we include the hot garbage that was james thrash 
 
Maybe because he played 80 more football games? And in an era where they didn't create rules to limit kickoff returns?

Hester has more TD's than Mitch in 4 less seasons. How is this even debatable? :wink:


Hester averaged more yards per Punt Return, AND more yards per Kick Return.

Mitchell just has hundreds more returns to his name is all.

If we're gonna adjust for rules changes then EVERY offensive player in the modern era is suspect. Brady, Manning included.

B Mitch also has a SB ring. Hester also benefited from rules changes on kick coverage. You can't ignore that.
 
Mitchell had 1070 career kick returns. (Punt and kickoff)
Hester had 566.

Mitchell has 9 Punt Return TD's and 4 Kick return TD's, 13 Total.

Hester has 14 Punt TD's alone. :lol: :lol: :lol:



*Also 5 kickoff returns, and 1 FG return.



It's not close, not even a little. Hester is the greatest kick returner in NFL history, if they can let a punter in, they can let a returner in, Hester should be that man.
 
Who else returns the opening kickoff of the SB to the house?

The GOAT that's who

My fav Hester return still has to be that 108/9 yard fg against the Giants,dude faked everyone out thinking he'd take a knee :lol:
 
Last edited:
Mitchell had 1070 career kick returns. (Punt and kickoff)
Hester had 566.

Mitchell has 9 Punt Return TD's and 4 Kick return TD's, 13 Total.

Hester has 14 Punt TD's alone. :lol: :lol: :lol:



*Also 5 kickoff returns, and 1 FG return.



It's not close, not even a little. Hester is the greatest kick returner in NFL history, if they can let a punter in, they can let a returner in, Hester should be that man.

Mitchell has over 4,000 rushing and receiving yards and 16 TDs. Great all around player. What's Hester's numbers outside of returning? Trash.
 
 
brian Mitchell is probably the only thing skins and eagles can agree upon..

unless we include the hot garbage that was james thrash 
No djax love? Donovan mcnabb [emoji]128064[/emoji]
pretty sure skins fans aren't overly fond of the mcnabb era.. and giving up a 2nd round pick for him

and djax act wore thin for the eagles' with constantly asking for a new deal or to renegotiate
Irving Fryer?
mehhh

surprised no one has thrown out trotter
 
Last edited:
Mitchell had 1070 career kick returns. (Punt and kickoff)
Hester had 566.

Mitchell has 9 Punt Return TD's and 4 Kick return TD's, 13 Total.

Hester has 14 Punt TD's alone. :lol: :lol: :lol:



*Also 5 kickoff returns, and 1 FG return.



It's not close, not even a little. Hester is the greatest kick returner in NFL history, if they can let a punter in, they can let a returner in, Hester should be that man.

Mitchell has over 4,000 rushing and receiving yards and 16 TDs. Great all around player. What's Hester's numbers outside of returning? Trash.

So are you moving the goal posts? Aren't they talking teams play? Those rushing and receiving yards are pedestrian and don't make his resume prettier
 
So are you moving the goal posts? Aren't they talking teams play? Those rushing and receiving yards are pedestrian and don't make his resume prettier

It does. All around football player. Not a one trick pony. To amass 10,000 more returning yards isn't a small number. Regardless of the attempts. 16,000 all purpose yards in a decade. Super Bowl champion.
 
Mitchell had 1070 career kick returns. (Punt and kickoff)
Hester had 566.

Mitchell has 9 Punt Return TD's and 4 Kick return TD's, 13 Total.

Hester has 14 Punt TD's alone. :lol: :lol: :lol:



*Also 5 kickoff returns, and 1 FG return.



It's not close, not even a little. Hester is the greatest kick returner in NFL history, if they can let a punter in, they can let a returner in, Hester should be that man.

Mitchell has over 4,000 rushing and receiving yards and 16 TDs. Great all around player. What's Hester's numbers outside of returning? Trash.

Hester in the slot on Madden though. [emoji]128293[/emoji]
 
You keep calling Mitchell and all around player...but the MAJORITY of his yards came on his returns.

Both guys (he and Hester) would have to get in for ST play. Hester was far more dynamic and more of a game-changer. It's a no-brainer who the better player is. I mean, for a season, this dude averaged 17.1 on PUNT RETURNS!
 
If we're gonna adjust for rules changes then EVERY offensive player in the modern era is suspect. Brady, Manning included.

B Mitch also has a SB ring. Hester also benefited from rules changes on kick coverage. You can't ignore that.

We do adjust for rule changes. Otherwise QBs like Matt Stafford would be HOF locks


Hester >


B Mitch was nasty, just not HOF nasty
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom