- Jan 17, 2009
- 35,076
- 47,202
Don't care how hated the prequels are, can you imagine how big the ****storm would be if they decanonized George's stories and made their own canon? There would be riots just out of principle.
Last edited:
Star Wars Universe Thread: May The 4th Be With You
Don't care how hated the prequels are, can you imagine how big the ****storm would be if they decanonized George's stories and made their own canon? There would be riots just out of principle.
- Nov 20, 2007
- 87,866
- 50,387
Bail Organa was mentioned in the OG trilogy so they can mention and use him for future movies.
I'm talking about characters and concepts that originated in the prequels. FOX still owns the rights to that.
Yeah he showed up in the prequels played by Smits but he was already name dropped before.
So unless Jar Jar gets name dropped I think that's the case.
Last edited:
- Nov 20, 2007
- 87,866
- 50,387
Well somebody said George made sure it was a part of the deal/contract in selling the rights to Disney.
If that's true, it doesn't matter that Hollywood likes to do reboots and remakes.
There's a similar situation with the creator and owner to Back to the Future. He straight up said it will never be remade.
Only way it happens now is if 100 years from now laws change and the property ends up in public domain like Dracula and Frankenstein's monster.
- Aug 14, 2012
- 23,005
- 27,720
Im sayin.
Theres are other stories to tell, why you guys like watching the same ones over and over is beyond me.
- Aug 2, 2011
- 2,181
- 577
Oh if it was brought up before then yeah but it'd go differently. No Dooku? Or Grievous? Padme (at least the name)? Qui-Gin
Keep in mind some trash is no limits as well like the prophecy, force child, midichlorians, Jar Jar, etc.
Who? Bail Organa?
He was mentioned in ANH first.
Bail Organa was mentioned in ANH?
- Sep 24, 2013
- 8,726
- 3,487
Agreed, **** is silly for a universe as big as Star Wars is
Oh if it was brought up before then yeah but it'd go differently. No Dooku? Or Grievous? Padme (at least the name
Keep in mind some trash is no limits as well like the prophecy, force child, midichlorians, Jar Jar, etc.
Who? Bail Organa?
He was mentioned in ANH first.
Bail Organa was mentioned in ANH?
Yes, Leia mentions him right at the start before her planet is ever destroyed.
big j 33
Supporter
- May 31, 2006
- 36,041
- 16,799
Loved it.
The first act dragged a bit, but once it settles in the movie really shines. I think they did a fine job getting us to care about these characters for the most part. But it seems like they could have dug another level deeper in the character development for most. Those are nitpicks there but one stage from greatness in that department.
The action? The best we've ever seen for Star Wars. Outstanding direction for the battle sequences, both in the air and on the ground and the final act blew my mind.
The final Vader scene was just awesome. Many of us wanted an entire movie of that in the prequels, so seeing that now was great fan service.
Felicity Jones did a fine job. I'd put Daisy Ridley's performance over hers, but I was pleased to see her get a big stage. The rest of the cast was excellent in what they were given, but maybe one more level and layer makes their characters shine even more. I wasn't moved that strongly by Whitaker dying, for example, so maybe a little more development makes those characters more rounded.
I loved Base and Chirrut and K2 was hilarious.
A little too much Tarkin, definitely started to notice and feel his CGI but it was still cool to see. And the final cameo was awesome.
All in all, I loved it and I can't wait to watch it again.
The first act dragged a bit, but once it settles in the movie really shines. I think they did a fine job getting us to care about these characters for the most part. But it seems like they could have dug another level deeper in the character development for most. Those are nitpicks there but one stage from greatness in that department.
The action? The best we've ever seen for Star Wars. Outstanding direction for the battle sequences, both in the air and on the ground and the final act blew my mind.
The final Vader scene was just awesome. Many of us wanted an entire movie of that in the prequels, so seeing that now was great fan service.
Felicity Jones did a fine job. I'd put Daisy Ridley's performance over hers, but I was pleased to see her get a big stage. The rest of the cast was excellent in what they were given, but maybe one more level and layer makes their characters shine even more. I wasn't moved that strongly by Whitaker dying, for example, so maybe a little more development makes those characters more rounded.
I loved Base and Chirrut and K2 was hilarious.
A little too much Tarkin, definitely started to notice and feel his CGI but it was still cool to see. And the final cameo was awesome.
All in all, I loved it and I can't wait to watch it again.
Last edited:
- Aug 2, 2011
- 2,181
- 577
Agreed, **** is silly for a universe as big as Star Wars is
Yes, Leia mentions him right at the start before her planet is ever destroyed.
this is mind blowing. I've seen that movie 100 times and I don't think I ever noticed the name being said. I'm gonna go watch again tonight, is it when she is on the death star in the room with vader and tarkin about to see her planet destroyed?
- Oct 9, 2006
- 57,664
- 29,658
I finally got a chance to check out a Rogue One Hot Toys display at a mall here.
Wanted to share a few pics with you guys...
And because we are NT, here are Donnie's Lunars!
The details on the Porcelain-Trooper were amazing.
Wanted to share a few pics with you guys...
And because we are NT, here are Donnie's Lunars!
The details on the Porcelain-Trooper were amazing.
- Aug 12, 2013
- 10,749
- 14,781
Awesome pics! Porcelain trooper is insane 
- Feb 18, 2001
- 1,076
- 367
man that display is nuts I want that at-st
- Aug 23, 2004
- 14,106
- 6,328
- Sep 23, 2012
- 32,830
- 24,897
The opening of Episode 3 with the battle over coruscant is one of the greatest moments in the whole franchise. The movie literally after the opening crawl puts you in the middle of a war amongst the stars.
Prequel hate is understandable yet unwarranted for the most part.
Prequel hate is understandable yet unwarranted for the most part.
- Jan 17, 2009
- 35,076
- 47,202
- Dec 14, 2001
- 12,426
- 2,239
I would love to see the movie before the reshoots. Just to see what they took out and changed.
Yeah, no.
You grew up with the prequels, so apparently that waters down your understanding of good films. Not your fault.
The opening battle in 3 is indeed good. One of the best in the franchise? Not even top 10. Maybe top 20.
Read thru some of the dialogue in that film again. Really, read thru it....Not unwarranted at all. Should be even more hate about it honestly.
*Note, the Sith Novel is actually quite a bit better. More in depth dialogue between Anakin/Palpatine. I enjoyed the film compared to I-II, but the book was better overall.
- Feb 18, 2001
- 1,076
- 367
I agree the space battle in rots is baller AF and it's definitely my favorite prequel , I'm still partial to the rotj space battle myself the interior of the death star ,executor crashing into it and Lando getting out right before the explosion were dope
Last edited:
- Feb 14, 2007
- 21,603
- 18,654
Word. My top three space battles so far are;
1) ROTJ
2) ROTS
3) Rogue One
4) ANH SE
I really do like the two X-Wing scenes in TFA as well, but they really need to do a big space battle in the Episode VIII. Trying to see them T-85's in action too. Hopefully, since those will be the latest model of the X-Wing, they can do more tricks than all these previous ones
Last edited:
- Jan 15, 2005
- 1,741
- 1,046
I hate this whole you grew up with the prequels bull. I grew up with the original trilogy and guess what I still have revenge of the sith as the 2nd best out of all them. You hate the prequels great but not everyone has to have your opinion
- Apr 18, 2014
- 8,756
- 5,707
^^ Aside from Hayden Christensen's acting, I enjoyed Revenge of the Sith.
I enjoyed Sith too, have said so several times. Doesn't make it "good".
Better than I-II by far, absolutely agree. It gets lumped in with the others unfairly simply by definition of being a prequel. I wish it could be classified as an OG to wash the prequel label.
But in terms of overall, OG's, TFA, and R1 are all better overall films. Sith had a strong emotional payoff that helps it but still a ton of garbage within it. Padme dying over sadness, dialogue, Anakin turning inside of five minutes, not killing a single Jedi, etc. Like I said, the emotional payoff covers a lot of those warts.
And I actually thought Hayden did pretty good in Sith, all things considered.
Last edited:
- Nov 20, 2007
- 87,866
- 50,387
Leia's father/adopted father. Unless I just got the worst memory, his name/he was mentioned/referred to in passing?Oh if it was brought up before then yeah but it'd go differently. No Dooku? Or Grievous? Padme (at least the name
Keep in mind some trash is no limits as well like the prophecy, force child, midichlorians, Jar Jar, etc.
Who? Bail Organa?
He was mentioned in ANH first.
Bail Organa was mentioned in ANH?
Last edited:
- Feb 18, 2001
- 1,076
- 367
Yeah they never mention him as bail organa just that her father knew Ben Kenobi from the clone wars
- Sep 24, 2013
- 8,726
- 3,487
This type of patronizing statement is completely unnecessary.
- Sep 23, 2012
- 32,830
- 24,897
I always assumed Hayden's delivery of his lines was to emulate the dramatic tone JEJ spoke with when voicing Vader. Essentially showing why Vader speaks with such a "shakesperean" tone
