Official Pizza Appreciation!

As a NY'er I salute Chicago & their pizza culture. Most NY'ers never ever use a fork & knife to eat their pizza(myself included) but Chicago's deep dish there's just no other way to eat it. I tried eating it normally by folding it first but there was no way that was happening. Them deep dish slices are too thick, too full & too heavy to be folded. Folding it just resulted in a big hot mess. I absolutely love Chicago. A city so full of vibes, history, cuisine, culture. You name it Chicago has it. Bang Bang Pies was the best food spot I tried there. Can't wait to go back.

Respect bro

If you need recommendations on anything lmk

Also a lot of people don’t know this, but the deep dish in general is a tourist thing. Chicago is actually known for our cracker like tavern style. Go to the south side (you’ll be ok) and go to Vito and Nicks. Get a sausage and hot giardanara pizza. That is authentic Chicago.

Don’t get me wrong I love Lou’s and other deep dish tho.
 
I had to stop fooling with Chicago deep dish, it’s a guaranteed food coma if you eat more than 1 slice. Only had giordano’s and it’s great but the pie crust hardens when you reheat it. Chicago deep dish eats more like lasagna than pizza.
 
Respect bro

If you need recommendations on anything lmk

Also a lot of people don’t know this, but the deep dish in general is a tourist thing. Chicago is actually known for our cracker like tavern style. Go to the south side (you’ll be ok) and go to Vito and Nicks. Get a sausage and hot giardanara pizza. That is authentic Chicago.

Don’t get me wrong I love Lou’s and other deep dish tho.
Vito & Nicks is :emoji_fire: .What are your go-to tavern spots aside from Vito & Nicks? I posted some Chicago spots earlier incase you missed it...

If you're ever in the Chicago area, here's a quick guide to some of my favorite places based on Pizza type.


Lou Malnati's - Deep Dish
I grew up on Lou Malnatis but there's no bias here. The sauce, the cheese, the crust all work together to create the perfect Chicago Deep Dish Pizza.
Tip: Throw in the extra change for the Butter Crust. The Fried Calamari is also worth a try.
IMG_20200822_175540__02.jpg

IMG_20200822_175721__01.jpg



Pequod's - Pan Pizza
Some may argue it's Chicago Deep Dish but it's more of a Pan Style Pizza. It's like a combo of Detroit Style and Deep Dish. The Focaccia like dough is thick and airy and has a delicious Caramelized Crust.
IMG_20201006_174941__01.jpg



Vito & Nick's - Chicago Tavern Style
Vito & Nick's has always been a Taven Style staple in Chicago. They started the Chicago Taven Style Pizza back in the 40's. Most Tavern Style Pizzas in the city have too thick of a doughy crust. I prefer their cracker thin crust. It looks unassuming, but it's all in the sauce & thin crust flavor with this one.
IMG_20201015_193530__01.jpg



Pizza Fried Chicken Ice Cream - #2 Tavern Style
This is a new spot that opened up in the Bridgeport area by a group of young, layed back folks that have gained a lot of momentum due to their attention to detail and quality ingredients. They don't mess around. The Taven style is cracker thin with exceptional char.
IMG_20211015_211535__02.jpg

IMG_20211015_211923.jpg



Pizza Fried Chicken Ice Cream - Sicilian
Not too many Sicilian joints in Chicago. PFCI takes the cake regardless. The dough is perfectly airy & yet crunchy and the sauce & toppings complement that with just the right balance.
IMG_20211015_211412__01.jpg



Union Squared - Detroit Style
More & more Detroit Style spots are starting to pop up around the city. This would have never been acceptable in the 80's or 90's lol. So far my top pick is Union Squared. Light, fluffy, great sauce, and the caramelized crusts hits.
IMG_20210612_205758__02.jpg

IMG_20210612_205812__02.jpg



Jimmy's Pizza Cafe - New York Style
More NY Pizza spots are popping up in Chicago as well. I've tried most & so far Jimmy's holds the crown. Owners are from New York and have made a name for themselves here with their NY pies. If the Foster spot is too far North, they just purchased a building in Wrigglyville but the opening date is still unknown.
IMG_20201128_184703__01.jpg

IMG_20200821_214601__05.jpg



Spacca Napoli - Neapolitan
I've been on a Neapolitan run for the past year. I still have a couple more places to try but Spacca Napoli is at the top of the heap. If you find yourself here your going to want to try the Pistachio Pizza. It's more of a low key choice but the flavors are life changing.
IMG_20211003_170538__01.jpg

IMG_20211003_171303__01.jpg


Honorable Mentions...


Home Run Inn
IMG_20201022_202343__01.jpg



Napoli Per Tutti
IMG_20211204_162444.jpg



Panino's Pizzeria
IMG_20210410_204350__02.jpg



Fat Chris's Pizza and Such
IMG_20210918_202126__01.jpg

IMG_20210918_202025__01.jpg



Bob's Pizza
IMG_20210529_221830__01.jpg



Coalfire
IMG_20200916_172340__02.jpg



Piece Brewery
IMG_20200916_172405__01.jpg
 
Last edited:
I had to stop fooling with Chicago deep dish, it’s a guaranteed food coma if you eat more than 1 slice. Only had giordano’s and it’s great but the pie crust hardens when you reheat it. Chicago deep dish eats more like lasagna than pizza.
Giordano's is meh. Never was a fan. They put that extra layer of crust on top of the cheese like it's a lasagna. And the outer crust is way too thick. The cheese tastes okay but they use too much. No bueno.
 
walkingBred walkingBred solid list bro you hit some great spots for sure


As far as tavern style,

Palermo’s, Roseangela’s, Phil’s, Pat’s, Milanos, off top for that thin, crispy vibe. You can put down like 20 slices haha
 
Lou’s chicago classic.

The goat of deep, pause

Born and raised in Chicago.

Also go to the south loop location

Actually just go and eat it fresh
Lol Lou's def is the goat of deep, pause again. If I remember correctly we went to a Suburban location for Lou's & a downtown location for Giordano's. Giordano's can't be confused or mistaken for any other deep dish given it's enormous crust lol.
 
Respect bro

If you need recommendations on anything lmk

Also a lot of people don’t know this, but the deep dish in general is a tourist thing. Chicago is actually known for our cracker like tavern style. Go to the south side (you’ll be ok) and go to Vito and Nicks. Get a sausage and hot giardanara pizza. That is authentic Chicago.

Don’t get me wrong I love Lou’s and other deep dish tho.
Def will let you know next time I go. Yeah I found that out too after my 2nd visit. Most out of towners define Chicago's pizza scene based off of the cities deep dish variants when infact deep dish really isn't genuine ChiTown identity. I wish I could try the sausage but I can only eat halal meat.
 
When I was there we found a halal Giordano's on yelp. But they had such horrendous reviews that we didn't even bother trying it. checks mcgee checks mcgee Have you tried Epic Burger? And Bang Bang Pies on N California Ave? I rave about Bang Bang Pies. Their food is heavenly & abzolutely on another tier.
 
i only tried lou malnatis when i was in Chicago... so i havent tried much deep dish pizza to say which one is the best.... but lou malnatis was bangin to say the least..once i go back to Chicago its the first pizza spot im hitting up and than ill hit up the other ones
 
Last edited:
When I was there we found a halal Giordano's on yelp. But they had such horrendous reviews that we didn't even bother trying it. checks mcgee checks mcgee Have you tried Epic Burger? And Bang Bang Pies on N California Ave? I rave about Bang Bang Pies. Their food is heavenly & abzolutely on another tier.

Haven’t been to either

I think those are more so chains

I wanna go to NYC low key just for the pizza and bagels lol

🤝 to everyone on the Lou’s and yes the loyalist and au cheval are goated burger wise. Throw in the BnG burger from Bop n Grill and you have my top 3. If you want a fire *** fast burger go to Red Hot Ranch or The Region.
 
Next time im in Chicago im a try au cheval... some chick i met at the bar worked there and told me to try it out.. didnt have time cuz i had a wedding to go to but ill try this summer... i want to try and catch a cubs game at wrigley
 
Go to the south side (you’ll be ok) and go to Vito and Nicks. Get a sausage and hot giardanara pizza. That is authentic Chicago.

haven't been since like 2019-ish but Is Vito and Nicks still cash only?

Last few times I've walked in and ordered only to run across the street to the Dollar Store for the atm. :lol:
 
Haven’t been to either

I think those are more so chains

I wanna go to NYC low key just for the pizza and bagels lol

🤝 to everyone on the Lou’s and yes the loyalist and au cheval are goated burger wise. Throw in the BnG burger from Bop n Grill and you have my top 3. If you want a fire *** fast burger go to Red Hot Ranch or The Region.
Come through man. Everything is open. Just mask up, get vaxxed if you aren't already. They have a vaccine mandate here if you want to sit & dine-in. Lmk I'll give you some spots. We have the best pizza & bagels around 😁It's all in our tap water.
 
Back
Top Bottom