- 2,041
- 75
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2010
Offical All Star Reserves Thread
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by im not you,
- Start date
- 383
- 10
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2010
Originally Posted by Im Not You
Originally Posted by StroShow4
Who would you suggest I take out to include Westbrook? He's got better numbers than Ginobili, but Manu's closed out so many games for the Spurs and they have the best record in the league. Deron Williams has similar numbers... I guess there's an argument to be made there. I feel like LaMarcus Aldridge deserves it for carrying the Blazers with all those injuries. Everyone else I listed in the West I feel HAVE to be included.
Argument?
Again...Westbrook is the ONLY player in the NBA averaging 20+, 5, 8. I think Deron should be an AS...but over Westbrook? No way.
Ok, that's fair. I think Westbrook has been plenty good enough, I just have a hard time removing anyone I listed to give him his spot.
- 383
- 10
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2010
Originally Posted by Im Not You
Originally Posted by StroShow4
Who would you suggest I take out to include Westbrook? He's got better numbers than Ginobili, but Manu's closed out so many games for the Spurs and they have the best record in the league. Deron Williams has similar numbers... I guess there's an argument to be made there. I feel like LaMarcus Aldridge deserves it for carrying the Blazers with all those injuries. Everyone else I listed in the West I feel HAVE to be included.
Argument?
Again...Westbrook is the ONLY player in the NBA averaging 20+, 5, 8. I think Deron should be an AS...but over Westbrook? No way.
Ok, that's fair. I think Westbrook has been plenty good enough, I just have a hard time removing anyone I listed to give him his spot.
- 2,509
- 111
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2011
gasol is having a better season than duncan, but if they'd play the same amount of minutes i think the ppg would be the same, and the spurs have the best record. either way duncan will be an all star whether it is as a starter or a sub. no doubt that popovich would select him.
Kg isnt really having an all star season. his points are down, his team is having a good record not because of him. more cause of rondo, pierce and allen. i wouldnt pick josh smith, i'd pick boozer over kg.
so is it a numbers game to all of you or is it who has the best record? cause if it is based on record, the griffin and love arent even an option, if it is a numbers game then kg is not an option or shaq.
Kg isnt really having an all star season. his points are down, his team is having a good record not because of him. more cause of rondo, pierce and allen. i wouldnt pick josh smith, i'd pick boozer over kg.
so is it a numbers game to all of you or is it who has the best record? cause if it is based on record, the griffin and love arent even an option, if it is a numbers game then kg is not an option or shaq.
- 2,509
- 111
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2011
gasol is having a better season than duncan, but if they'd play the same amount of minutes i think the ppg would be the same, and the spurs have the best record. either way duncan will be an all star whether it is as a starter or a sub. no doubt that popovich would select him.
Kg isnt really having an all star season. his points are down, his team is having a good record not because of him. more cause of rondo, pierce and allen. i wouldnt pick josh smith, i'd pick boozer over kg.
so is it a numbers game to all of you or is it who has the best record? cause if it is based on record, the griffin and love arent even an option, if it is a numbers game then kg is not an option or shaq.
Kg isnt really having an all star season. his points are down, his team is having a good record not because of him. more cause of rondo, pierce and allen. i wouldnt pick josh smith, i'd pick boozer over kg.
so is it a numbers game to all of you or is it who has the best record? cause if it is based on record, the griffin and love arent even an option, if it is a numbers game then kg is not an option or shaq.
- 17,642
- 23,982
- Joined
- Nov 11, 2007
- 17,642
- 23,982
- Joined
- Nov 11, 2007
- 8,956
- 39
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2007
Since when the hell has that been a measuring stick for who should be an all star or not?Originally Posted by Im Not You
Gasol should make it, and what do numbers have to do with anything? KG is playing some of the best defense of anyone in the league.Originally Posted by SCuse7
Gasol's having a better season, though so I feel he would get the start over TD based on that although the Spurs have the better record.Originally Posted by Storm2006
Originally Posted by TheGoldenChild
no he doesnt deserve it. not based on numbers, he missed 9 games. and kg is not the only one that got the celtics the winning record. pierce, allen, rondo, even shaq deserve to be all stars then.
i think stern should replace yao with duncan. he can easily play center. and is in the same situation as gasol, who isnt a true center either.
It's an individual accomplishment. Numbers mean ALOT. If they didn't...then why are we even ENTERTAINING the idea of Love/Griffin being in the game?
So if you don't put up stats you can't make the all-star game? I just don't see who is deserving over KG
- 8,956
- 39
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2007
Since when the hell has that been a measuring stick for who should be an all star or not?Originally Posted by Im Not You
Gasol should make it, and what do numbers have to do with anything? KG is playing some of the best defense of anyone in the league.Originally Posted by SCuse7
Gasol's having a better season, though so I feel he would get the start over TD based on that although the Spurs have the better record.Originally Posted by Storm2006
Originally Posted by TheGoldenChild
no he doesnt deserve it. not based on numbers, he missed 9 games. and kg is not the only one that got the celtics the winning record. pierce, allen, rondo, even shaq deserve to be all stars then.
i think stern should replace yao with duncan. he can easily play center. and is in the same situation as gasol, who isnt a true center either.
It's an individual accomplishment. Numbers mean ALOT. If they didn't...then why are we even ENTERTAINING the idea of Love/Griffin being in the game?
So if you don't put up stats you can't make the all-star game? I just don't see who is deserving over KG
- 2,509
- 111
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2011
Originally Posted by SCuse7
Since when the hell has that been a measuring stick for who should be an all star or not?Originally Posted by Im Not You
Gasol should make it, and what do numbers have to do with anything? KG is playing some of the best defense of anyone in the league.Originally Posted by SCuse7
Gasol's having a better season, though so I feel he would get the start over TD based on that although the Spurs have the better record.Originally Posted by Storm2006
Originally Posted by TheGoldenChild
no he doesnt deserve it. not based on numbers, he missed 9 games. and kg is not the only one that got the celtics the winning record. pierce, allen, rondo, even shaq deserve to be all stars then.
i think stern should replace yao with duncan. he can easily play center. and is in the same situation as gasol, who isnt a true center either.
It's an individual accomplishment. Numbers mean ALOT. If they didn't...then why are we even ENTERTAINING the idea of Love/Griffin being in the game?
So if you don't put up stats you can't make the all-star game? I just don't see who is deserving over KG
boozer
- 2,509
- 111
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2011
Originally Posted by SCuse7
Since when the hell has that been a measuring stick for who should be an all star or not?Originally Posted by Im Not You
Gasol should make it, and what do numbers have to do with anything? KG is playing some of the best defense of anyone in the league.Originally Posted by SCuse7
Gasol's having a better season, though so I feel he would get the start over TD based on that although the Spurs have the better record.Originally Posted by Storm2006
Originally Posted by TheGoldenChild
no he doesnt deserve it. not based on numbers, he missed 9 games. and kg is not the only one that got the celtics the winning record. pierce, allen, rondo, even shaq deserve to be all stars then.
i think stern should replace yao with duncan. he can easily play center. and is in the same situation as gasol, who isnt a true center either.
It's an individual accomplishment. Numbers mean ALOT. If they didn't...then why are we even ENTERTAINING the idea of Love/Griffin being in the game?
So if you don't put up stats you can't make the all-star game? I just don't see who is deserving over KG
boozer
- 3,766
- 382
- Joined
- Jan 1, 2009
Monta Ellis needs to make the squad.
- 3,766
- 382
- Joined
- Jan 1, 2009
Monta Ellis needs to make the squad.
- 11,629
- 62
- Joined
- Nov 22, 2002
got tickets to the Rookie Challenge, please don't let Blake make the All-Star team.
- 11,629
- 62
- Joined
- Nov 22, 2002
got tickets to the Rookie Challenge, please don't let Blake make the All-Star team.
- 2,509
- 111
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2011
no one wants steve nash as an allstar?16.8 and 11.1
- 2,509
- 111
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2011
no one wants steve nash as an allstar?16.8 and 11.1
- 2,509
- 111
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2011
no one wants steve nash as an allstar?16.8 and 11.1
- 2,509
- 111
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2011
no one wants steve nash as an allstar?16.8 and 11.1
- 12,536
- 39
- Joined
- May 5, 2009
west:
pau (should replace yao)
dirk
love (he has to be!)
westbrook
duncan
poster child
aldrigde
d.will
man too many deserving players on the west
i'll be cool just as long as pau, d.will, blake and love make it
east:
pierce
rondo
josh smith
horford
boozer
allen
(kanye shrug)
pau (should replace yao)
dirk
love (he has to be!)
westbrook
duncan
poster child
aldrigde
d.will
man too many deserving players on the west
i'll be cool just as long as pau, d.will, blake and love make it
east:
pierce
rondo
josh smith
horford
boozer
allen
(kanye shrug)
- 12,536
- 39
- Joined
- May 5, 2009
west:
pau (should replace yao)
dirk
love (he has to be!)
westbrook
duncan
poster child
aldrigde
d.will
man too many deserving players on the west
i'll be cool just as long as pau, d.will, blake and love make it
east:
pierce
rondo
josh smith
horford
boozer
allen
(kanye shrug)
pau (should replace yao)
dirk
love (he has to be!)
westbrook
duncan
poster child
aldrigde
d.will
man too many deserving players on the west
i'll be cool just as long as pau, d.will, blake and love make it
east:
pierce
rondo
josh smith
horford
boozer
allen
(kanye shrug)
DYNAMICS
formerly diplomat tdot
- 28,578
- 3,769
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2002
There's an hour pre-show on TNT tonight right?
DYNAMICS
formerly diplomat tdot
- 28,578
- 3,769
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2002
There's an hour pre-show on TNT tonight right?
- 4,325
- 10
- Joined
- Sep 12, 2007
Edit: My bad, people might want to wait to see it on TV.
- 4,325
- 10
- Joined
- Sep 12, 2007
Edit: My bad, people might want to wait to see it on TV.
