- Jul 11, 2006
- 33,452
- 12,581
lol just to continue to play devil's advocate... and to pick up on your "McFadden had the team on his back" argument...Originally Posted by Sorkoram
That was McFadden's trophy..team was on his back ALL season with Felix sharing carries
321 vs South Carolina
With Dennis Dixon under center, the Ducks were 8-1 (1 yard away from being undefeated), riding a wave of momentum coming off two huge wins against top 10opponents, ranked #2 in the country, dominating in the Pac 10, and in most (if not all people's eyes) the best team in the country.
Dixon tears his ACL against Arizona State (but completes the game) and STILL starts against Arizona and then runs (on a completely torn ACL) 39 yards for atouchdown (geeeeez) before being pulled in the 1st quarter for essentially blowing out his knee.
Oregon goes on to fall apart and lose THAT game as well as the next two against much weaker opponents (even getting shutout by an awfulll UCLA team.)
He was arguably the best player on any field that year, but no one was as huge for his team as Dixon was. Not even Tebow, who as someone said already,wasn't even the best player on his own team.
And McFadden had a lot of help from Felix. Remove him from the equation and that teams record is even worse, and I doubt this would be an argument, even withMcFadden putting up monster numbers on a 5 or 6 win team.
just sayin...
=
?
it shoulda.