WHERE WOULD U RANK BRANDON ROY IN TERMS OF BEST PLAYERS IN THE NBA??

[wjun15]

B-Roy and D-Will are equal to me.

------------- G MPG FG% 3p% FT% REB APG SPG BPG TO PPG
Brandon Roy78 37.2 .480 .377 .824 4.70 5.1 1.13 .28 1.95 22.6
D. Williams 68 36.8 .471 .310 .849 2.90 10.7 1.07 .29 3.35 19.4

they play almost the exact same minutes, of the 8 positive categories listed, B-Roy has the edge 5-3, throw in TO's and he has it 6-3. B-Roy also is slightly more clutch when it counts IMO.

So those of you acting like its crazy to even compare the two....don't know what to tell you, other than you're wrong.
agreed...Roy's turnover rate is overlooked...i dont think any other guard averages 2.0 or less of his caliber...

 

[japanair21]

Originally Posted by WJuN15

B-Roy and D-Will are equal to me.

------------- G MPG FG% 3p% FT% REB APG SPG BPG TO PPG
Brandon Roy78 37.2 .480 .377 .824 4.70 5.1 1.13 .28 1.95 22.6
D. Williams 68 36.8 .471 .310 .849 2.90 10.7 1.07 .29 3.35 19.4

they play almost the exact same minutes, of the 8 positive categories listed, B-Roy has the edge 5-3, throw in TO's and he has it 6-3. B-Roy also is slightly more clutch when it counts IMO.

So those of you acting like its crazy to even compare the two....don't know what to tell you, other than you're wrong.

agreed...Roy's turnover rate is overlooked...i dont think any other guard averages 2.0 or less of his caliber...
If he had near 10 assists a game, expect that to almost double.

 

[airmaxpenny1]

According to Efficiency rating dude is the 6th best player in the League I believe.

 

[mjsaver]

Dirk is seriously OVERATED, same dude who got SHUTDOWN by Stephen Jackson

When it matters Dirk never comes thru, man please J Terry got way more heart & leadership than Dirk.

Durant is good , but hes mostly perimiter, hes to young n weak to finish at the rim with contact.

Meanwhile B-roy is catchin and 1 dunks.

B-Roy is better than Dirk & Durant, theyre good but b-roy is much more efficent and versatile.

 

[kobe8is]

Originally Posted by ElderWatsonDiggs

Originally Posted by Chester McFloppy

He doesn't play in Cleveland so he's better than LeBron.
He doesn't rape women so he's better than Kobe.
He doesn't have herpes, so he's better than DWade.

Probably #1.

How long did it take you to coem up with that...and don't lie, you keep checking this post to see how many people lol'ed at that joke. For the record that wasn't funny.

BINGO!!!

Roy might be in my top 10!

 

[osh kosh bosh]

Originally Posted by airmaxpenny1

According to Efficiency rating dude is the 6th most efficient player in the League I believe.

Fixed PER doesn't mean they are the best it's just how efficient they are, weather you think that makes them the best is your prerogative.

Originally Posted by MJsaver


Dirk is seriously OVERATED, same dude who got SHUTDOWN by Stephen Jackson

When it matters Dirk never comes thru, man please J Terry got way more heart & leadership than Dirk.

Durant is good , but hes mostly perimiter, hes to young n weak to finish at the rim with contact.

Meanwhile B-roy is catchin and 1 dunks.

B-Roy is better than Dirk & Durant, theyre good but b-roy is much more efficent and versatile.

 

[tooeasy891]

Top 15

 

[mben32]

Originally Posted by airmaxpenny1

According to Efficiency rating dude is the 6th best player in the League I believe.

Thats wassup.

Originally Posted by MJsaver


Dirk is seriously OVERATED, same dude who got SHUTDOWN by Stephen Jackson

When it matters Dirk never comes thru, man please J Terry got way more heart & leadership than Dirk.

Durant is good , but hes mostly perimiter, hes to young n weak to finish at the rim with contact.

Meanwhile B-roy is catchin and 1 dunks.

B-Roy is better than Dirk & Durant, theyre good but b-roy is much more efficent and versatile.

ARE YOU SERIOUS?

Durant>>>>>Roy.

 

[yungmatt]

%@**$ really just said Dirk is overrated

 

[marionthebarberian]

Originally Posted by MJsaver


Dirk is seriously OVERATED, same dude who got SHUTDOWN by Stephen Jackson

When it matters Dirk never comes thru, man please J Terry got way more heart & leadership than Dirk.

Durant is good , but hes mostly perimiter, hes to young n weak to finish at the rim with contact.

Meanwhile B-roy is catchin and 1 dunks.

B-Roy is better than Dirk & Durant, theyre good but b-roy is much more efficent and versatile.

ska, can you just ban this person?

 

[sickwitit]

Originally Posted by MJsaver


Dirk is seriously OVERATED, same dude who got SHUTDOWN by Stephen Jackson

When it matters Dirk never comes thru, man please J Terry got way more heart & leadership than Dirk.

Durant is good , but hes mostly perimiter, hes to young n weak to finish at the rim with contact.

Meanwhile B-roy is catchin and 1 dunks.

B-Roy is better than Dirk & Durant, theyre good but b-roy is much more efficent and versatile.

Just log off please.

Dirk isn't versatile? He doesn't come through? Durant is too weak and young to finish? %*$ does age have to do with anything? And please post clips ofBroy catching and1 dunks, haven't seen them yet.

 

[sickwitit]

Oh, here's a few more, just so you can take those thoughts out your head.

 

[kaimel rule]

Roy better than Durant?

Some of your guys are going crazy now. Time to delete this thread

 

[marionthebarberian]

I still cannot get over him saying Dirk is overrated and roy is better...can you please explain to me how that is possible?

 

[713 STUNNA]

Top twenty towards the bottom..

 

[DCAllAfrican]

Would be easier/more efficient to rank him by position.
I hate comparing players that don't play the same position.

SO in terms of SG's where would you rank him

 

[tarvald drama chase]

how can u compare Dwill and Roy's turnover numbers?? do you forget that Roy iS NOT A POINT GUARD, and therefore has the ball in his hands way less than DWILL... that is a dumb argument, and a non comparable one.. of course a PG Is going to have more turnovers than a 2 guard.... that is just plain dumb to thinkotherwise...

 

[casperjr]

im not gettin in this cuz the dudes thats sayin he better are fan boys so theres no gettin to them

and yall saying that he better by showin hiss stats with stats of somebody haveing a down year doesnt help you it hurts you

 

[tarvald drama chase]

haha this clown said that Dirk is overrated and Durant is too young and weak... notice how both are in the top 6in scoring... hmmmmm

 

[foshizzle]

Originally Posted by Tarvald Drama Chase

how can u compare Dwill and Roy's turnover numbers?? do you forget that Roy iS NOT A POINT GUARD, and therefore has the ball in his hands way less than D WILL... that is a dumb argument, and a non comparable one.. of course a PG Is going to have more turnovers than a 2 guard.... that is just plain dumb to think otherwise...

True, then again you can't compare assist numbers in that case either and thats D-Will's only real stat advantage on B-Roy.

Casper- Take a look at D-Will's stats and you'll see this year is the best of his career. So your "down year" argument doesn't cut it.

 

[bangdak]

although that statement was stupid, durant, physically is weak for a foward.

 

[tarvald drama chase]

^ who cares, it hasnt affected him, or slowed him down thus far... so whats it matter

and fshizzle-
good point, but then look at the fact that D-will is avg a double double, and broy isnt... no matter what category it is

 

[franchise 55]

Melo is a scorer no doubt, but I think Roy is a much better overall player. Also

at that dude trying to justify himself by using "and 1 dunks" as a point.

 

[tarvald drama chase]

^.... no....

 

[wjun15]

good point, but then look at the fact that D-will is avg a double double, and broy isnt... no matter what category it is


but then look at kobe, lebron, wade...they arent averaging a double double right? the turnover point is valid, cuz he averages way less than other"SG's"...