- May 30, 2006
- 25,304
- 13,356
I think the intention was good but the execution has been poor and there has been plenty of unexpected drawbacks.
The idea was to allow those prospects who were 100% secure in their decision to sign early. No more visits, no more coaches calling and texting you all the time. For a lot of high school kids it can be overwhelming and distracting so I get the idea of wanting to end it early.
In execution, it's been poor. Early signing day should only be for those prospects who don't want to visit anymore, aren't waiting on a better offer. Early signing should only be for those 20%-25% of prospects who are actually ready. For example, Georgia had a player named Dom Blaylock who committed immediately after he was offered as a sophomore and didn't take a visit or entertain another school the entire time he was in high school. This is who the early signing period Is designed for.
If you still think you need to take a visits or you're waiting on a better offer, don't sign early!
Now the early signing period has become the de facto NSD and 90% of prospect sign early when that wasn't the idea. Now you have the unintended consequence of the early signing period pushing, coaching, hiring/firing earlier and earlier.
As others have mentioned, the early signing period be in August, prior to football season If it exists at all If it exists at all. But this brings the added issue of what to do if the coach who recruited you leaves or gets fired?
If you're going to do an ESD, it needs to be before the season starts. Not immediately after.It's because a lot of kids say they hate recruiting and want an early signing day where they can end the process and just enjoy their last year. Regular school kids have an early signing period: Early decision, which typically falls on 12/1-12/15 (November for Cali I think). They wanted to give the football kids an option similar.
What they SHOULD do is have an early action date on August 31 or something, where kids can do that financial aid paperwork and get locked in with the school with guaranteed scholarships but not be forced to attend. But I know schools hate that because it doesn't benefit them at all when the kid has a whole extra year. The real reason the early signing day is in December is cuz schools want that senior year tape.
Or allow Juniors and Seniors who know where they're going to both sign in February or some time in the summer (for juniors) of their respective class years. Schools won't want that because you're right - the want the tape - but that's the only way it feels like this works.
It's just dumb to have it placed where it is. "Hey sign now or wait two months with a nice dead period thrown in there." Stupidity.