NFL Discussion Thread - Hall of Fame Game: August 3rd

Status
Not open for further replies.
If this were any other season, I'd say Eli could easily shake this off and throw 4 tds, but he's just looked outright bad this year, and this time, you can't blame it on his o-line.
 
The Giants aren't trading Eli Manning. That'd be like when the Knicks traded Ewing.

Jerry Reese isn't that incompetent.:lol
 
Longevity, the position, and the market he plays in will make him a lock with two SB mvp

Exactly. I'm not sure why dudes don't understand this. Be it right or wrong Eli is HOF bound. Not to mention he beat the so called invincible Patriots/Brady not once but twice.
 
Eli been overrated. Forget the Super Bowl arguments for now because like I've said all along...So much more goes into it then a flash in the pan run by a quarterback.

Great quarterbacks continually have their play fall off like Eli's does. This isn't just this game talkin' either. I've said this for years.

"The nerdlucks are at the game"
 
Nice to see Jacobs grow his balls back

beastly run
 
Last edited:
If this were any other season, I'd say Eli could easily shake this off and throw 4 tds, but he's just looked outright bad this year, and this time, you can't blame it on his o-line.

yeah he's been terrible all season. hasn't helped that the team has sucked massively overall, but he's had very little focus. just sloppy and irresponsible
 
Marshall is a monster. You have to appreciate how good this cat is. Once he retire people will look back and realize how underrated he was.
 
 
I said basically though, Elis numbers pre this disaster warrants a HoF induction and he wont play this bad forever.
His actual numbers do not warrant it. His winning percentage doesn't warrant it. His two Superbowl runs are all that support it. Not enough IMHO. He's not nearly consistent enough a player to be in the Hall as a QB.
 
i would take eli on my team if it meant 2 super bowls but alot of terrible seasons also
 
Y'all heard about how the league is going to fine B Marsh for wearing his green shoes?

They are meant to raise awareness about mental health, I wonder why the NFL wouldn't endorse something like that.
eyes.gif
 
 
I said basically though, Elis numbers pre this disaster warrants a HoF induction and he wont play this bad forever.

His actual numbers do not warrant it. His winning percentage doesn't warrant it. His two Superbowl runs are all that support it. Not enough IMHO. He's not nearly consistent enough a player to be in the Hall as a QB.

THIS!
 
Y'all heard about how the league is going to fine B Marsh for wearing his green shoes?



They are meant to raise awareness about mental health, I wonder why the NFL wouldn't endorse something like that.
eyes.gif

Because they won't profit from it and does violate the uniform rules, Marshall will match the fine and donate it to charity though
 
Maybe I'm undervaluing what it takes to be in the hall right now, and over rating the rings but I still think hes going to go. He wont be amongst the greats, and the narrative on him will be pretty clear. He needs a run game and a defense behind him, hes not one of those do it all win every game by himself type of QBs. 
 
Y'all heard about how the league is going to fine B Marsh for wearing his green shoes?

They are meant to raise awareness about mental health, I wonder why the NFL wouldn't endorse something like that. :rolleyes


They will pull the "can't deviate from policy, otherwise opens a can of worms"


But the NFL does need to promote men's health MUCH better than it does
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom