antidope
Supporter
- 63,179
- 67,232
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2012
Fixed. The best form of giving is anonymous to anonymous.
I dont get it
Jay Z says 'My presence is charity', compares self to Obama in response to Harry Belafonte's critici
- 32,800
- 19,699
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2012
we
well that's a little extreme. parts of his life can serve as inspiration perhaps to some, but he should not be viewed as the end all be all. there's other accomplished african-american figures out there to look up to and admire if that's an issue
well that's a little extreme. parts of his life can serve as inspiration perhaps to some, but he should not be viewed as the end all be all. there's other accomplished african-american figures out there to look up to and admire if that's an issue
Last edited:
gllahone84
Banned
- 11,727
- 1,912
- Joined
- Jul 10, 2011
Let's not forget about Jaz now.
Last edited:
- 12,422
- 2,916
- Joined
- Jul 6, 2008
Why wouldn't they? I know Beyonce has supported that family since last year. You think Jay feel like he has something to prove to Belafonte?
- 5,296
- 3,389
- Joined
- Jun 14, 2007
Many of us are not hating. I dont hate Jay-Z. I just dont think he is an inspiration for anyone or is a charitable person.
- 5,892
- 6,287
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2012
But jayz has been this way since day one...
This dude has never been conscious or rhymed like Common Sense( he even told you guys this,lol)
Now do I wish two of the biggest African American entertainers in the world would take a stand and put their necks out there to truly talk about the plight of poor and disenfranchised people,that would be awesome...
But it's not going to happen and that's sad but on the other hand I am tired of people looking up to false idols for opinions....We(not only African Americans) but the people of the US really need to unplug from the Matrix and fight for what they believe and when we fight " stand our ground", dont just protest for a month then go back and eat chick fil a or if you truly feel a certain way about an artist( jayz, Yeezus,etc) boycott their products.. This generation suffers from ADHD and as long as it doesn't impede on their liberties, they could give two *****...
This dude has never been conscious or rhymed like Common Sense( he even told you guys this,lol)
Now do I wish two of the biggest African American entertainers in the world would take a stand and put their necks out there to truly talk about the plight of poor and disenfranchised people,that would be awesome...
But it's not going to happen and that's sad but on the other hand I am tired of people looking up to false idols for opinions....We(not only African Americans) but the people of the US really need to unplug from the Matrix and fight for what they believe and when we fight " stand our ground", dont just protest for a month then go back and eat chick fil a or if you truly feel a certain way about an artist( jayz, Yeezus,etc) boycott their products.. This generation suffers from ADHD and as long as it doesn't impede on their liberties, they could give two *****...
- 7,728
- 3,807
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2011
Meh, I rock with Jay and he's an inspiration to me.
I can see the positives that he's doing and how the same ones the built you up, call for your head when you get too successful.
Definitely a double edged sword and a reason to be isolated in your own belief system and protective self-confidence.
I can see the positives that he's doing and how the same ones the built you up, call for your head when you get too successful.
Definitely a double edged sword and a reason to be isolated in your own belief system and protective self-confidence.
am1x90xnike
Banned
- 3,034
- 1,217
- Joined
- May 21, 2013
Here is someone here to say that he is an inspiration for me. There are many others, from Malcom to Ghandi, form Martin to Lincoln, Socrates to Alexander, Aesop to Confucious. I have many influences, Jay-z is one, he is probably the biggest because he is from the same situation that I am from. So to not think he is an inspiration to anyone, here is someone he is. And as far as charity, it's a fact that he does a lot of charity, as much as any other celebrity. So you can either ignore those who draws inspiration from his life and ignore the fact that he does charity. There are things called "facts. That is why people call you a hater, not because he doesn't inspire you or doesn't meet your definition of "charitable person" but he does inspire people and does do charity.
gllahone84
Banned
- 11,727
- 1,912
- Joined
- Jul 10, 2011
I don't think he can even compare with those guys...AT ALL.
Seriously?
No way. Especially Malcolm, Ghandi, and Martin.
But maybe you're not comparing Jay to those guys, and if so my b. Just looks like it after you mentioned their names and followed up with Jay Z.
Last edited:
- 41,962
- 43,587
- Joined
- Oct 8, 2002
Jay lost touch YEARS ago...
- 1,964
- 350
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2012
"If skills sold, truth be told, I'd probably be Lyrically Talib Kweli
Truthfully I wanna rhyme like Common Sense But I did 5 mill' - I ain't been rhyming like Common since"
Truthfully I wanna rhyme like Common Sense But I did 5 mill' - I ain't been rhyming like Common since"
- 3,783
- 2,337
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2003
Pretty sure that's an Outliers joke.
Also, y'all should read The Unwinding by George Packer. He breaks down the concept of the 21st century American, and does a really interesting profile on Jay Z.
Also, if y'all wanna look down on Jay Z, then look down on the Kennedys, the founding fathers, just about every important American whose had a real impact on our culture and way of life.
America is a nation built on criminals laundering their money.
- 7,728
- 3,807
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2011
If they stakes were higher now, like they were in the 60's....y'all would have turned your backs on Jay and let him get murked just like Malcolm did when he had a change of ideology.
The masses are good for nothing but to be led.
- 7,626
- 442
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2008
Considering he is calling his PRESENCE charity I highly doubt he gives anonymously.
- 12,503
- 925
- Joined
- Feb 8, 2009
Jay motivated me to get my entreprenegro on. 
The image of Jay rocking a suit & tie back in the day sparked so many young black dudes in high school.
Cam had grown dudes rocking pink tees, Wayne got the hood tatting they face and buying red bandannas from beauty salons.
Post 2003 Jay had dudes rocking button ups and suits, motivated black entrepreneurship and black success in the corporate world
So yea his "image" is a charity. His moves as a black man who we've seen come from the bottom to almost a billie provides "Hope" to the young black who actually wants similar success.
The image of Jay rocking a suit & tie back in the day sparked so many young black dudes in high school.
Cam had grown dudes rocking pink tees, Wayne got the hood tatting they face and buying red bandannas from beauty salons.
Post 2003 Jay had dudes rocking button ups and suits, motivated black entrepreneurship and black success in the corporate world
So yea his "image" is a charity. His moves as a black man who we've seen come from the bottom to almost a billie provides "Hope" to the young black who actually wants similar success.
Last edited:
- 11,242
- 17,967
- Joined
- Jul 27, 2012
What if belafonte tried contacting jay-z behind the scenes but jay didn't give him the time of day.
That doesn't seem to far fetched considering Robert DeNiro was tight at jay for ignoring his calls last year, so maybe belafonte tried discussing this in private but was ignored.
That doesn't seem to far fetched considering Robert DeNiro was tight at jay for ignoring his calls last year, so maybe belafonte tried discussing this in private but was ignored.
- 3,783
- 2,337
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2003
Jay motivated me to get my entreprenegro on.
The image of Jay rocking a suit & tie back in the day sparked so many young black dudes in high school.
Cam had grown dudes rocking pink tees, Wayne got the hood tatting they face and buying red bandannas from beauty salons.
Post 2003 Jay had dudes rocking button ups and suits, motivated black entrepreneurship and black success in the corporate world
So yea his "image" is a charity. His moves as a black man who we've seen come from the bottom to almost a billie provides "Hope" to the young black who actually wants similar success.
- 7,728
- 3,807
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2011
That does seem far-fetched seeing that neither one of them mentioned it.
- 4,053
- 643
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2010
Lord forbid the man who has fought for justice and equality half his life using his money to back the civil rights movement and got Fidel Castro to approve of hip hop in Cuba wants a successor .This man whose best years are behind him and doesn't have that long to live wants a successor for his people's sake .The fact jay z called him a boy and insulted him shows what type of man he is .Jay was quicker to do an anti semitisim ad faster than he was to do any other outreach .Hov is a hyper capitalist he can talk all that anonymous charity crap but let's be real he is quick to champion the nets or a clothing brand yet he won't mention a charity by name .
- 25,908
- 22,870
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2013
"Really try to think about Jay's "my presence is charity" one-liner and those clunkyMCHG verses for a moment. "My presence is charity" turns Jay Z into some Ayn Randian beyond-good-and-evil force who changes the world just by waking up in the morning. That he also compared his presence to Obama's is downright offensive, because it isn't just that Obama's existence as president makes him inspirational, it's that his role as president allows him to bring about change. The American presidency isn't a symbolic abstraction like the Queen of England or the King of New York Rap. Meanwhile, those lines from "Nickel and Dimes" suggest that any critique of his actions just can't be tolerated. Jay Z is a rapper, which means he's a rhetorician, which means he knows exactly what he's doing here. This isn't money-grubbing rap-dude cluelessness, or even delusion. It's a power move. He's ending a conversation that should be allowed to continue, because ending it works to his advantage."
BTW, Belafonte's argument is the same argument that I have brought up in the past. Like it or not, our celebrities have a responsibility to our youth.
BTW, Belafonte's argument is the same argument that I have brought up in the past. Like it or not, our celebrities have a responsibility to our youth.
Last edited:
- 7,954
- 5,065
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2007
@ these stories of dudes being inspired by Jay in this thread just to battle against the hate for him.Yall dudes don't got nothing better to do.
- 6,377
- 4,135
- Joined
- Nov 27, 2007
To me, no mans presense is charity. Not Obama, not Jay-z, not anybody. That's not enough. Your **** stinks too. You are not god. By the sound of some of you, you would bow down to this man. Who much is given then much is required.
That's the only problem I have with the statement he made. I'm sure he donates a bunch of money but your presense is not charity.
To me, he is nothing but a successful musician and entrepreneur. Thats it. He is not a revolutionary like Bob Marley or Peter Tosh who used music as a way to fight for human rights. He has never been outspoken about any of those issues. That's not a knock to Jay but this why his presense is just not enough. Who the **** do you think you are? How can I take you seriously when most of your music is about materialism and how much weight you pushed? What is your cause other than making more money?
This is not say he isn't great at what he does but lets all remember, he is nothing but a successful musician and entrepreneur. He is not the first black president, MLK, or Malcom. To me, he cannot be mentioned amongst those men.
Now, I can understand how he can be someone to look up to but I would hope that he is not your only role model. I would hope your Parents have a bigger influence but I understand some aren't as fortunate to have great parents to look up to.
That's the only problem I have with the statement he made. I'm sure he donates a bunch of money but your presense is not charity.
To me, he is nothing but a successful musician and entrepreneur. Thats it. He is not a revolutionary like Bob Marley or Peter Tosh who used music as a way to fight for human rights. He has never been outspoken about any of those issues. That's not a knock to Jay but this why his presense is just not enough. Who the **** do you think you are? How can I take you seriously when most of your music is about materialism and how much weight you pushed? What is your cause other than making more money?
This is not say he isn't great at what he does but lets all remember, he is nothing but a successful musician and entrepreneur. He is not the first black president, MLK, or Malcom. To me, he cannot be mentioned amongst those men.
Now, I can understand how he can be someone to look up to but I would hope that he is not your only role model. I would hope your Parents have a bigger influence but I understand some aren't as fortunate to have great parents to look up to.
Last edited:
- 7,728
- 3,807
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2011
Last semester I saw a poster for the Shawn Carter Scholarship fund giving $2,500 Grants to anyone convicted of a drug crime and therefore ineligible for Federal/State Tuition assistance.
Is that considered charity, or nah?
Is that considered charity, or nah?
antidope
Supporter
- 63,179
- 67,232
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2012
To combat the hate? Nope, someone asked if anyone's actually been inspired by him and I responded.
Yall dudes don't got nothing better to do.
me it is. He's giving away money and to people who otherwise wouldn't get it.
- 7,127
- 772
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2007
Dude is the Will Smith of the rap game. Always plays it safe and never takes a risk
