2019-20 NFL thread: Thread's dead. Move into spacedoodoo's

[jjs07]

Why not?
Both are hall of famers

For starters, one is usually in the conversation for GOAT, and the other isn't. Even with both being in the HOF, there are levels to this....

 

[100027]

Where does Ed Reed rank in the best ever? He’s the best I’ve seen

 

[aNYone]

Where does Ed Reed rank in the best ever? He’s the best I’ve seen

1.

Even as a Niners fan I put him over lot. Reed would flourish in any era.

Imagine if Reed played now when they throw all over the place

He’d make the Pro-Bowl from the 2 Bengals games alone.

 

[JBII]

1.

Even as a Niners fan I put him over lot. Reed would flourish in any era.

Imagine if Reed played now when they throw all over the place

He’d make the Pro-Bowl from the 2 Bengals games alone.

and lead the league in pi calls and unnecessary roughness.

 

[spacedoodoo]

Yea.

Reed, bdawk, troy, lynch, all those guys would have their games somewhat neutralized with these new rules in the league.

Definitely would've been good though because of their individual skills.

 

[SpittaJetLife]

This Baldinger breakdown of Ed Reed interceptions is dope. He was a monster.

 

[numbah1grimey]

and lead the league in pi calls and unnecessary roughness.

Nah. Ed could hit, but his #1 attribute was to get the FOOTBALL. He’s not a head hunter like Jamal Adams or some of these non-hands having DBs. He could play in any era. Ed would average 8 interceptions per year.

He’s the epitome of a ballhawk. I don’t know why DBs don’t adopt the Ed Reed, Deion, Rod Woodson mentality. IDGAF about big hits. Get me a interception and get 6 while doing it

 

[CP1708]

Ed Reed or Brian Dawkins?

I would take Ed Reed in my opinion.

Randy Moss or Greg Camarillo?

I would take Randy Moss in my opinion.

 

[jjs07]

Ed Reed could do everything. No weaknesses in his game.

GOAT.

 

[numbah1grimey]

Cowboys took Terrence Newman in that draft. Should’ve traded back for Ed reed

 

[jjs07]

Ed Reed probably had the highest defensive IQ of any DB who ever played as well. His instincts were off the charts.

Can't remember the year, but when he was at UM, he pretty much stole the ball from a teammate (who got an INT) as they were falling and he made a few cuts to take it to the house. It was a big play because the game was close

 

[numbah1grimey]

Ed Reed probably had the highest defensive IQ of any DB who ever played as well. His instincts were off the charts.

Can't remember the year, but when he was at UM, he pretty much stole the ball from a teammate (who got an INT) as they were falling and he made a few cuts to take it to the house. It was a big play because the game was close

2001. Boston College. That game saved their season

 

[JBII]

Nah. Ed could hit, but his #1 attribute was to get the FOOTBALL. He’s not a head hunter like Jamal Adams or some of these non-hands having DBs. He could play in any era. Ed would average 8 interceptions per year.

He’s the epitome of a ballhawk. I don’t know why DBs don’t adopt the Ed Reed, Deion, Rod Woodson mentality. IDGAF about big hits. Get me a interception and get 6 while doing it

yeah

 

[Clyde Frog]

If you had to pick Charles Woodson or Ed Reed

 

[JBII]

If you had to pick Charles Woodson or Ed Reed

Chuck but im a homer. Hes the reason i played football growing up and wore #2. Hes my favorite player ever.

 

[IATT]

If you had to pick Charles Woodson or Ed Reed

Ed, easily

 

[IATT]

Randy Moss or Greg Camarillo?

I would take Randy Moss in my opinion.

CP goin CP

If Ed is moss.. Dawkins is like TO

 

[Clyde Frog]

I asked before looking at the numbers and tbh it kind of feels like the answer is obviously Woodson.

Granted they play different positions but Charles often played a safety role. And simply played everywhere. Which i’d rather have.

64 Int’s, 33 Forced Fumbles, 20 Sacks 13 TD’s

 

[aNYone]

If you had to pick Charles Woodson or Ed Reed

See I think that this is tougher than Reed vs. Dawkins.

 

[SpittaJetLife]

Best corner ever?

 

[spacedoodoo]

Woodson lowkey better.

 

[reaperslilbruh]

If it’s just safety, I’m taking Reed. If I need a hybrid, Woodson. In a vacuum, Reed.

 

[numbah1grimey]

Best corner ever?

Deion. Straight outta Fote’ Myers

 

[JBII]

Ed, easily

easy? lmao ok

 

[DeadsetAce]

Ed Reed my #1 safety as well

Also liked Troy more than Dawk