- May 4, 2009
- 3,401
- 1,612
as long as my ***** chewy has a line or 4 im good 
Star Wars Universe Thread: May The 4th Be With You
- Mar 8, 2010
- 21,800
- 3,553
Yup. Yup. Yup. That's exactly me.
Fair enough.
Good article.
Last edited:
- Mar 8, 2010
- 21,800
- 3,553
I think he meant the difference between hard science fiction and pop sci-fi. Like the difference between Children of Men and The Fifth Element. Not that it wasn't creative. It's just...Star Wars is the most famous science fiction. And when that is pretty basic and popcorn, and takes the crown away from a 2001: A Space Odyssey...it influences everyone to be basic and popcorn.
And it did. I remember seeing an old interview on YT of Spielberg responding to critics, cuz I guess all the foreign critics **** on his movies, saying he was influencing a generation to dumb their movies down. I think it's like that. Science fiction was always an intelligent thing. You build a world to speak on the one we live in. To say something about the human condition in a way straight drama can't. I think Star Wars influenced everyone to paint in big, bold simple colors. And to make sure there's a toyline on the way.
But light sabers are cool.
And it did. I remember seeing an old interview on YT of Spielberg responding to critics, cuz I guess all the foreign critics **** on his movies, saying he was influencing a generation to dumb their movies down. I think it's like that. Science fiction was always an intelligent thing. You build a world to speak on the one we live in. To say something about the human condition in a way straight drama can't. I think Star Wars influenced everyone to paint in big, bold simple colors. And to make sure there's a toyline on the way.
But light sabers are cool.
- Mar 8, 2010
- 21,800
- 3,553
Here's the article he was linking to How 'Star Wars' ruined sci-fi
View media item 959695
I don't know what to tell ya.
View media item 959695
I don't know what to tell ya.
Last edited:
- Dec 30, 2012
- 3,768
- 1,120
Yeah, that article is whiny bull ****.
Boo hoo, a book you like hasn't been adapted. Awwww.
So ******* what? Lucas created this movie out of thin air, not copied some book. Lack of ideas? F that.
I see there could be a point about dumbing down the genre, but fault the other "artists" for not creating their own ideas.
That article is garbage.
Boo hoo, a book you like hasn't been adapted. Awwww.
So ******* what? Lucas created this movie out of thin air, not copied some book. Lack of ideas? F that.
I see there could be a point about dumbing down the genre, but fault the other "artists" for not creating their own ideas.
That article is garbage.
- Mar 8, 2010
- 21,800
- 3,553
He just said Star Wars was a negative influence on sci-fi films...and it was. Dude just came at it from a balanced perspective trying to convert the nonbelievers, and that makes more sense to me than Kool-Aid speak.
No kool aid here tho. I hate George Lucas. Think I've been clear on that.
But that idea line needs to get edited out or somethin.
Negative influence......eh. Should have opened MANY doors. Proved you could do anything not of this world if you put the same attention to detail in your script.
If others couldn't figure it out, shouldn't be on George. Hell, he his own damn self screwed up his own creation after a while.
But that idea line needs to get edited out or somethin.
Negative influence......eh. Should have opened MANY doors. Proved you could do anything not of this world if you put the same attention to detail in your script.
If others couldn't figure it out, shouldn't be on George. Hell, he his own damn self screwed up his own creation after a while.
- Jan 17, 2009
- 35,088
- 47,218
heh
- Dec 30, 2012
- 3,768
- 1,120
Yeah CP is my dude but I knew I wasn't the only one who caught the huge irony in that post
- Mar 8, 2010
- 21,800
- 3,553
But yeah that's my point, he's not talking about Star Wars in a vacuum for himself. Everyone and their moms saw it when it came out. And if you grew up in the 70s or 80s, there was something wrong with you if you didn't watch it. But if you grew up in the 90s?...watched it after you saw the prequels?...that's what this was for. It showed how it became 60s, 70s and 80s baby crack, and for it's time, had a super massive influence, for better or worse.
And cmon with that 'opening the world up.' Star Wars came after 2001: A Space Odyssey and Planet of the Apes. They did it bigger than anyone ever and then some, but don't act likethey invented big screen sci-fi, and without them there'd be nothing. Hell the Star Trek show came out 10 yrs before it.
Last edited:
big j 33
Supporter
- May 31, 2006
- 36,056
- 16,831
I'm going to save you a lot of time.. you're not going to change CP's mind even a little in regards to anything Star Wars related.
- Mar 8, 2010
- 21,800
- 3,553
Thing is, I don't get what his point is, or what he's complaining about. Little thought, of any kind? Star ******* Wars?????
Now, is he referring to the prequels, or the original trilogy? I hope like hell he is talking about the prequels. He'd still be wrong, but less wrong at least.
Ok, this is a little better. Only problem to his logic, the prequels were all derived from the OG script. Everything spoken of in the first films were alluding to works they hadn't even begun yet. How the hell is that lack of originality? Do we have ANY other franchise that started with the 4th movie, ever? Like really, ever?
No, right? So then he can shove his lack of originality up his ***.
I see. Let's see.....Wars, Star, Wars. So, how many machine gun fights can we sit thru in movies about war? How many airplanes do we have to watch fly, in movies about airplanes? How many cars do I have to watch drive fast, in Fast and Furious? The damn franchise is about Wars, in the Stars. In those wars, they use lasers, light sabers, and space ships. When we start filming movies about the Revolutionary War with ninja swords instead of muskets, then he can complain.
The heroes fighting for good, and the villains fighting for evil use light sabers to battle. How that's difficult to comprehend, I have no idea. Maybe Captain America needs to put away his shield in the 3rd film to avoid being "unoriginal"
Clearly doesn't mean me. I don't want JJ recycling a God damn thing. There is plenty of new material out there, if they fail to use it, that's on them. I'll be sittin over here with my "told you so".
I assume he didn't finish that trilogy.
Very creative, plugging into the "real world" to fight karate style, for all 3 movies.
But the series that can travel to a billion different planets, with a billion species, and countless good or bad guys, all with backgrounds, that span thousands of years, and feature countless wars and battles across centuries of time in space, lacks creativity.
All because other directors/studios/writers didn't do their own exploring into the reaches of space. The one franchise that lives "out there" lacks creativity and originality, but all the ones who failed to capitalize and do their own exploring, they were ruined by Star Wars success. Whatever.
Last edited:
Nike Jordan
Supporter
- Jun 27, 2002
- 34,011
- 81,471
I always laugh when geeks complain about "too much CGI" in Star Wars but every film in the last 15 years or so isn't fair game.
Everyone loves the Pixar films and they're all CGI.
Everyone loves the Pixar films and they're all CGI.
- Aug 23, 2004
- 14,106
- 6,328
Anytime I think of CGI overload, I think about the Agent Smith fight (Burly Brawl) in the matrix reloaded...
- Sep 17, 2005
- 10,807
- 3,560
- Feb 22, 2012
- 10,340
- 12,209
Episode 3 could've been good if Anakin didn't go from good guy to killing kids with no remorse and wanting to control the galaxy in a span of 15 mins. Absolutely no transition. I mean, the only questionable thing he did before that was get revenge on the sand people for killing his mother, now suddenly he's a psychopath?
Last edited:
- Feb 29, 2000
- 88,776
- 48,003
The prequels would have been way better without phantom menace. We should have never seen anakin as a little boy especially that little boy from jingle all the way.
Should have started from attack of the clones and developed slowly with his turn to the darkside slow but with hints along the way of confusion and temptation.
Also a different actor for anakin one that didnt seem so mute and boring. Luke was a loud whiny cornball. I would have liked to see someone like that.
They could have started with attack of the clones and instead of the clone wars cartoon they could have made a story for that as a second non animated movie
I would have loved to have seen that female sith in live action
Should have started from attack of the clones and developed slowly with his turn to the darkside slow but with hints along the way of confusion and temptation.
Also a different actor for anakin one that didnt seem so mute and boring. Luke was a loud whiny cornball. I would have liked to see someone like that.
They could have started with attack of the clones and instead of the clone wars cartoon they could have made a story for that as a second non animated movie
I would have loved to have seen that female sith in live action
- Feb 22, 2012
- 10,340
- 12,209
Agreed. His turn to the dark side should've been spread out over 3 films instead of one scene in the final film
heatpinoyboy
Supporter
- Aug 7, 2008
- 3,487
- 808
When I think of awesome lightsaber choreography (yeah its a videogame ) I always turn to this
]
) I always turn to this]
