QB THREAD - 2x quarterbacky award winner: Lamar Jackson

Andrew Luck wasnt great that day..

The Colts had 10 drives that day...4 3 and outs...5 punts...2 inteceptions...1 touchdown

You didn't answer the question.

Wanna tell me the score of the game before Luck through his first interception in this game?

The score was 31-7

I wasn't able to come in fully earlier to address some of what you're trying to say.

You say INT's matter, but that's not 100% correct. SOME INT's, matter, some do not.

Ryan Tannehill threw 12 last year. I watched every single snap, multiple times.

One of his first on they ear, vs Buffalo, came on the final play of the game. Down 29-10. INT matter?

2-3 of them came from WR's running the wrong route, or literally bouncing off their hands. Ryan's fault?


Russ threw 4 INT's in the NFCCG game, and won.
He threw 1 INT in the Super Bowl, and lost.

That one, in the Super Bowl? Was less than how many Tom Brady threw in the Super Bowl. Brady won.

Aaron Rodgers threw 2 in the NFCCG game. And he lost.


INT's matter? There were 6 in that game, and at the end of 4 quarters, it was still tied up.

So you can kinda see why some INT's are meaningless as hell. 3rd and 13, Luck drops back, throws a 50 yard deep ball, picked. Guess what? He just punted.

Russ throws an INT near his own 20, Ha Ha returns it inside the 5. Seattle D holds to a FG, it's only the 1st quarter. They can recover.
He throws INT on his own goalline, under a minute left, can't recover.

INT's on Hail Mary's, or even tipped off a WR's hands, sometimes **** just happens. Throw the ball enough, **** gonna happen more often.

You throw 616 passes, and 16 get picked, that's 600 other passes that were not intercepted. Six, hundred. And yet he has this rap that he throws too many picks, and over the course of a season, they somehow add up negatively.

1 a game. If he was throwin 23-24-25 a season, hey, that's gettin a little rough. But he's at 1 a game. With another 600 passes that were just fine.
If he threw 25 TD's, and 22 picks, yeah, that's a little on the poor side. He had a 40-16 split. That's pretty ok I'd say. I'm happy as hell with Tannehill giving me 27-12, I can't fathom 40-16. :lol
 
[COLOR=#red]
Just watched Jon Schnepp's documentary on that. Real good, interesting if anyone wants to watch.
The Death of Superman Lives.[/COLOR]

I was trying to find it on YouTube... Don't you have to buy it to see it?
 
Joe is the new Eli

Flacco is a very good playoff quarterback, but at least Eli has had seasons of carrying the team when the talent around him wasn't the greatest.

i would take russell before flacco

As would I, and I like what Russell can do.
 
Last edited:
8o
Andrew Luck wasnt great that day..
The Colts had 10 drives that day...4 3 and outs...5 punts...2 inteceptions...1 touchdown

Every NFL quarterback has interceptions that aren't his fault

2 of Russell Wilson's interceptions in the NFC Championship game weren't his fault..Does he get a pass on those?

For team like the Colts, who are built on offense, the interceptions definitely matter...in the 6 losses Andrew Luck had 10 tds and 10 ints

An prime example is vs the Eagles, the Colts were up 27-20 with 5 minutes left in field goal range and Luck threw an interception

That may be ok when you are just a good quarterback but when you are supposed to be elite like Andrew Luck is supposed to be..its fair to criticize his interceptions

I get that Andrew is throwing the ball alot but other quarterbacks like Ryan, Eli, Stafford have thrown the ball over 600 times with less interceptions than Andrew did in 2014

We don't give Aaron Rodgers a pass on his 6-5 playoff record..We didn't give Brady a pass for not winning a Super Bowl in almost decade

The point is when you start reaching the elite level, the expectations are higher and more criticizing of your game will come, you don't get excuses
 
Last edited:
LMAO. That Luck INT vs Philly? Defender pulled down TY, no call. Look it up. 8o
 
EqualBlankLamprey.gif
 
Let's post pics of every INT by Luck and RW and analyze which ones count
 
Mann too much Wilson vs Luck come on guys :lol

So I think Brady's performance in the Super Bowl was one of the best from a quarterback ever. Down 10 points in the second half against one of the best defenses of all time, dude methodically picked them apart with BIG throw after BIG throw. It's not like he just got some big plays on blown coverages or anything, those were long *** drives where he need to execute every throw. On that stage against that defense, I definitely think its one of the most impressive performances ever, thoughts?
 
Mann too much Wilson vs Luck come on guys :lol

So I think Brady's performance in the Super Bowl was one of the best from a quarterback ever. Down 10 points in the second half against one of the best defenses of all time, dude methodically picked them apart with BIG throw after BIG throw. It's not like he just got some big plays on blown coverages or anything, those were long *** drives where he need to execute every throw. On that stage against that defense, I definitely think its one of the most impressive performances ever, thoughts?

My thoughts are he picked on a CB that Cam newton was able to go 8-8 on
 
Mann too much Wilson vs Luck come on guys :lol

So I think Brady's performance in the Super Bowl was one of the best from a quarterback ever. Down 10 points in the second half against one of the best defenses of all time, dude methodically picked them apart with BIG throw after BIG throw. It's not like he just got some big plays on blown coverages or anything, those were long *** drives where he need to execute every throw. On that stage against that defense, I definitely think its one of the most impressive performances ever, thoughts?

My thoughts are he picked on a CB that Cam newton was able to go 8-8 on

a) injuries are part of the game
b) you're over simplying the fact that he picked apart YOUR ENTIRE defense in that 4th quarter. everyone except Sherman. the ball was being thrown all around the field. not just at simon (that's the kid's name, right?)
 
Last edited:
So I think Brady's performance in the Super Bowl was one of the best from a quarterback ever. Down 10 points in the second half against one of the best defenses of all time, dude methodically picked them apart with BIG throw after BIG throw. It's not like he just got some big plays on blown coverages or anything, those were long *** drives where he need to execute every throw. On that stage against that defense, I definitely think its one of the most impressive performances ever, thoughts?

Yeah its up there, probably a top 5-10 performance from a quarterback in the postseason
 
Mann too much Wilson vs Luck come on guys
laugh.gif


So I think Brady's performance in the Super Bowl was one of the best from a quarterback ever. Down 10 points in the second half against one of the best defenses of all time, dude methodically picked them apart with BIG throw after BIG throw. It's not like he just got some big plays on blown coverages or anything, those were long *** drives where he need to execute every throw. On that stage against that defense, I definitely think its one of the most impressive performances ever, thoughts?
I think he deserves credit.

I haven't rewatched the game so it's hard to say 
laugh.gif
.  But he certainly did a hell of a lot better than Peyton, Brees, or A-Rod ever did.  I wouldn't say he had me worried about the defense, but he was effective.  Rivers and Romo were the other two that managed to have good games against the Hawks.
 
Last edited:
I still haven't even watched highlites of XLV :lol

Losses in the SB hurt. Sorry Bills fan
 
Mann too much Wilson vs Luck come on guys :lol

So I think Brady's performance in the Super Bowl was one of the best from a quarterback ever. Down 10 points in the second half against one of the best defenses of all time, dude methodically picked them apart with BIG throw after BIG throw. It's not like he just got some big plays on blown coverages or anything, those were long *** drives where he need to execute every throw. On that stage against that defense, I definitely think its one of the most impressive performances ever, thoughts?

My thoughts are he picked on a CB that Cam newton was able to go 8-8 on

a) injuries are part of the game
b) you're over simplying the fact that he picked apart YOUR ENTIRE defense in that 4th quarter. everyone except Sherman. the ball was being thrown all around the field. not just at simon (that's the kid's name, right?)

I only remember KJ getting picked on when he was 101 with Gronk and Simon was bbq chicken all day. Maxwell and Sherman shut down their dudes
 
I still haven't even watched highlites of XLV
laugh.gif


Losses in the SB hurt. Sorry Bills fan
Yeah I will never, ever watch that game again.  I've seen each of those plays once and it will remain that way.

Sometimes there's a part of me that wants to watch the Kearse catch or the comeback but then I'm like, nah....
 
Mann too much Wilson vs Luck come on guys :lol

So I think Brady's performance in the Super Bowl was one of the best from a quarterback ever. Down 10 points in the second half against one of the best defenses of all time, dude methodically picked them apart with BIG throw after BIG throw. It's not like he just got some big plays on blown coverages or anything, those were long *** drives where he need to execute every throw. On that stage against that defense, I definitely think its one of the most impressive performances ever, thoughts?

My thoughts are he picked on a CB that Cam newton was able to go 8-8 on

a) injuries are part of the game
b) you're over simplying the fact that he picked apart YOUR ENTIRE defense in that 4th quarter. everyone except Sherman. the ball was being thrown all around the field. not just at simon (that's the kid's name, right?)

I only remember KJ getting picked on when he was 101 with Gronk and Simon was bbq chicken all day. Maxwell and Sherman shut down their dudes

TD catches by LaFell, Gronk, Amendola, Edelman. Simon covering all those dudes?

Simon got cooked by Edelman a couple times. Shane Vareen caught A TON of balls and I'm pretty sure Simon wasn't on him. Pretty sure
 
Back
Top Bottom