- 4,527
- 17
- Joined
- Oct 17, 2002
SO if the Raiders win will it be because the Raiders outplayed them and are the better team or will it be on Alex Smith?
:::[Official] San Francisco 49ers 2010-2011 Regular Season Thread-Sing Fired:::
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by niketalker23,
- Start date
TheGodFresco
formerly gsdoubleu
- 24,478
- 2,308
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2007
it depends how the game plays out...
- 6,549
- 2,596
- Joined
- Nov 4, 2002
Smith could have a 3 TD, 300yd+, 0 TO day and they would still blame it on Smith if they lost. The hate for Smith is more than some "49er fans" desire for the niners to flat out win
TheGodFresco
formerly gsdoubleu
- 24,478
- 2,308
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2007
it depends how the game plays out...
- 6,549
- 2,596
- Joined
- Nov 4, 2002
Smith could have a 3 TD, 300yd+, 0 TO day and they would still blame it on Smith if they lost. The hate for Smith is more than some "49er fans" desire for the niners to flat out win
- 17,246
- 73
- Joined
- May 19, 2004
Us sucking the past 5 years or so is not all Alex's fault...people just like to have an easy scapegoat, and it's always the quarterback. No question, his play is not starting QB material due to his inconsistency right now. But there have been far deeper problems on this team the past 5 years; Smith just happened to be in the middle of the mix. And for drafting Smith, you can blame Mike Nolan and his $*#%$#+ stupid draft rationales. He had Smith and Aaron Rodgers do this dumb rotate-the-football-around-your-waist drill, and Smith didn't complain like a yes-man, while Rodgers went "!#%?!?", so he drafted Smith instead.
- 17,246
- 73
- Joined
- May 19, 2004
Us sucking the past 5 years or so is not all Alex's fault...people just like to have an easy scapegoat, and it's always the quarterback. No question, his play is not starting QB material due to his inconsistency right now. But there have been far deeper problems on this team the past 5 years; Smith just happened to be in the middle of the mix. And for drafting Smith, you can blame Mike Nolan and his $*#%$#+ stupid draft rationales. He had Smith and Aaron Rodgers do this dumb rotate-the-football-around-your-waist drill, and Smith didn't complain like a yes-man, while Rodgers went "!#%?!?", so he drafted Smith instead.
- 12,536
- 39
- Joined
- May 5, 2009
as mentioned theyre playing better than we are obviously and no its all alex smith's fault but at the same time for the #1 pick comes expectations most of the blame is on him
no matter what the qb is the leader of the team and with the weapons he has this year he really has no more excuses
- 12,536
- 39
- Joined
- May 5, 2009
as mentioned theyre playing better than we are obviously and no its all alex smith's fault but at the same time for the #1 pick comes expectations most of the blame is on him
no matter what the qb is the leader of the team and with the weapons he has this year he really has no more excuses
- 8,859
- 577
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2007
it's a bit silly for you guys to throw out the words "casualties & cost them their job" when being tied in with alex smith.
Nolan -- has he been a Head Coach since? nope, he's making his money by being a very good Def. Coord.
Raye & Hostler -- no one cares about.
Martz -- Smith had nothing to do with him since he was NOT apart of the Martz offense.
Sing -- I really dont care for anymore. He's stuck in 1985. Should stick to motivational speaking
Then there are the other coordinators who went on to, get this, become HEAD COACHES else where. McCarthy and Norv(debatable) are doing themselves just fine. So where is the casualties here? Can't cost them their job if they ended up with a better job + more money.
Nolan -- has he been a Head Coach since? nope, he's making his money by being a very good Def. Coord.
Raye & Hostler -- no one cares about.
Martz -- Smith had nothing to do with him since he was NOT apart of the Martz offense.
Sing -- I really dont care for anymore. He's stuck in 1985. Should stick to motivational speaking
Then there are the other coordinators who went on to, get this, become HEAD COACHES else where. McCarthy and Norv(debatable) are doing themselves just fine. So where is the casualties here? Can't cost them their job if they ended up with a better job + more money.
- 8,859
- 577
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2007
it's a bit silly for you guys to throw out the words "casualties & cost them their job" when being tied in with alex smith.
Nolan -- has he been a Head Coach since? nope, he's making his money by being a very good Def. Coord.
Raye & Hostler -- no one cares about.
Martz -- Smith had nothing to do with him since he was NOT apart of the Martz offense.
Sing -- I really dont care for anymore. He's stuck in 1985. Should stick to motivational speaking
Then there are the other coordinators who went on to, get this, become HEAD COACHES else where. McCarthy and Norv(debatable) are doing themselves just fine. So where is the casualties here? Can't cost them their job if they ended up with a better job + more money.
Nolan -- has he been a Head Coach since? nope, he's making his money by being a very good Def. Coord.
Raye & Hostler -- no one cares about.
Martz -- Smith had nothing to do with him since he was NOT apart of the Martz offense.
Sing -- I really dont care for anymore. He's stuck in 1985. Should stick to motivational speaking
Then there are the other coordinators who went on to, get this, become HEAD COACHES else where. McCarthy and Norv(debatable) are doing themselves just fine. So where is the casualties here? Can't cost them their job if they ended up with a better job + more money.
- 8,323
- 730
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2007
if only alex smith could ever play like that.
FWIW i don't think alex smith has "cost" any coach their job... alex smith just happens to suck, a lot.
and the coaches that did happen to get fired, probably deserved it, and possibly alex smith's performance was a factor.
like NTL said,
nolan: has no idea how to be a head coach-- he was more interested in appearing on the cover of GQ than anything else.
ray and hostler: trash
martz: always was an offensive genius, but needed exact personnel. (did not coach alex smith, yes i understand)
singletary: has no idea how to be a head coach.
*edit*
and yeah,
alex smith: has no idea how to be an NFL qb
- 8,323
- 730
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2007
if only alex smith could ever play like that.
FWIW i don't think alex smith has "cost" any coach their job... alex smith just happens to suck, a lot.
and the coaches that did happen to get fired, probably deserved it, and possibly alex smith's performance was a factor.
like NTL said,
nolan: has no idea how to be a head coach-- he was more interested in appearing on the cover of GQ than anything else.
ray and hostler: trash
martz: always was an offensive genius, but needed exact personnel. (did not coach alex smith, yes i understand)
singletary: has no idea how to be a head coach.
*edit*
and yeah,
alex smith: has no idea how to be an NFL qb
- 12,536
- 39
- Joined
- May 5, 2009
add this to the list
alex smith: has no idea how to be an NFL qb
- 12,536
- 39
- Joined
- May 5, 2009
add this to the list
alex smith: has no idea how to be an NFL qb
- 7,568
- 32
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2005
Alex Smith did not take a single snap under Mike Martz.
- 7,568
- 32
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2005
Alex Smith did not take a single snap under Mike Martz.
- 8,323
- 730
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2007
yes i understand, i'm just talking about the people who have been fired from this organization. i should probably edit that before i get crucified.
- 8,323
- 730
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2007
yes i understand, i'm just talking about the people who have been fired from this organization. i should probably edit that before i get crucified.
- 24,333
- 42,668
- Joined
- May 15, 2005
meh i don't really hate the raiders but yep-- they are playing well, and SFO has Alex "what the *@%@ is a quarterback?" Smith
yeah i didnt hate the raiders because first off theyre not in my division and second we play them in the regular season like every what 5-6 years? so i could care less about them but its their fans that gets my blood going which subsequently led me to hating the whole raider organization
We have had 7 (?) offensive coordinators in 6 years. None have worked out. What is the common denominator?
________________________________________________
at the 49ers coaching staff/alex smith fraction.
teaching students about fractions just got a lot easier
- 24,333
- 42,668
- Joined
- May 15, 2005
meh i don't really hate the raiders but yep-- they are playing well, and SFO has Alex "what the *@%@ is a quarterback?" Smith
yeah i didnt hate the raiders because first off theyre not in my division and second we play them in the regular season like every what 5-6 years? so i could care less about them but its their fans that gets my blood going which subsequently led me to hating the whole raider organization
We have had 7 (?) offensive coordinators in 6 years. None have worked out. What is the common denominator?
________________________________________________
at the 49ers coaching staff/alex smith fraction.
teaching students about fractions just got a lot easier
- 17,269
- 8,922
- Joined
- Oct 8, 2003
Agreed. Alex Smith is costing people jobs left and right. Alex Smith is getting coaches fired with the 49ers year after year and he even got NikeTalker23 fired from making gameday threads. Next up is you Andrew630.
I will say this though. Alex and Sing need to go. Alex had enough oppertunities, and although I do think he tried his best, his best wasn't enough. He's not good enough to be the QB this team needs and it's time for a change. Both with Alex and Sing. Sing is a good guy and I will feel bad for him because we've been in some close games this season that we could have won, but 0-6 is unacceptable regardless of who our QB is. Especially with the talent we have. I just don't think he has the experience this team needs right now. We need a veteran coach, and unfortunately we also need a new OC. We need experienced and successful coaches as well as a proven QB.
- 17,269
- 8,922
- Joined
- Oct 8, 2003
Agreed. Alex Smith is costing people jobs left and right. Alex Smith is getting coaches fired with the 49ers year after year and he even got NikeTalker23 fired from making gameday threads. Next up is you Andrew630.
I will say this though. Alex and Sing need to go. Alex had enough oppertunities, and although I do think he tried his best, his best wasn't enough. He's not good enough to be the QB this team needs and it's time for a change. Both with Alex and Sing. Sing is a good guy and I will feel bad for him because we've been in some close games this season that we could have won, but 0-6 is unacceptable regardless of who our QB is. Especially with the talent we have. I just don't think he has the experience this team needs right now. We need a veteran coach, and unfortunately we also need a new OC. We need experienced and successful coaches as well as a proven QB.
- 8,406
- 41
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2009
LOL @ the 180 this thread took.
Alex Smith is no longer the problem
Alex Smith is no longer the problem
- 8,406
- 41
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2009
LOL @ the 180 this thread took.
Alex Smith is no longer the problem
Alex Smith is no longer the problem
