How tall are yall? Reason I ask is because while I don't call it "court feel", for guards when you're slipping in and out of places and have to make quick moves and avoid defenders and teammates alike, cushion is great but being able to really tell where your feet are while you're doing a move can be helpful to avoid stepping fully on someone else's foot, or knowing if you plant wrong, et cetera. You also get a clearer feel of how much traction you've got going on, and helps on defense to get a better sense of if you can quickly plant and get to a spot to make a steal or a block. This factors in even more if you have no vertical
Like yall have seen nightwing's videos. If he gets 6 inches off the ground, it's a good day. Though he's 'older', I have to take his words with a grain of salt if he's talking about cushion, because as you say, when you're coming down off a high leap, "court feel" is PAIN
For me it's a balance. When I play outside, I go for cushion, because these outside courts will wreck your joints no doubt. So like you I've been shooting around in One Takes & I just got some Why Nots. Also went out in Amber XXXIVs. But last year if I got hyped, I'd put on the Freak 1s and have a field day being lightning quick. I'm under 6 feet with decent bounce so shoe weight affects my play. But it's definitely a tradeoff between 'court feel' and cushion depending on how you feel that day, whether you're outdoors or indoors, or if the court is trash (even if indoors) or good. It also matters if you're playing half or full, and how big the court is. Some full courts are still small, but if you're at like a college gym, it can be damn near NBA size. So if you're going to be doing a ton of running, you need that cushion if you plan on playing for 2 hours. If you're playing for 2 ours but its outside and it's half court, you can probably get away with less cushion. If you're indoors playing half you can probably wear something as minimal as the freak 1s and get out of there with no pain. When I'd play in the freak 1s outside the joy I had in playing and winning games caught up to my *** the the next day, no doubt.