- 4,104
- 10
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2006
Originally Posted by DoubleJs07
Originally Posted by airmaxpenny1
How so? To me there's a top 4 that's cemented (Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Ben) tier and than after that its pretty fluid. Outside of those 4, give me Cutler I would have taken Rivers last year but he regressed this year, Matt Ryan is useless on the road and is loaded with weapons, Eli has loads of weapons and still makes crucial mistakes, Schuab loaded with weapons, Romo same thing. Cutler does more with less than anybody else. Dude is throwing to Hester and Knox, ##%+ his best reciever was Olsen and they traded him in the off-season. Look at how bad Hanne was abused Sunday, that offensive line is horrendous. Give Cutler weapons and a dome he would be up STATS.Originally Posted by DeadsetAce
jay cutler top 5?
i mean, he's def. won over critics this year...but top 5? really? pump those brakes...
Give Cutler weapons and he'd still pile up the INTs. He's not a top-5 QB, sorry. If you're going to get on Eli for making mental mistakes, then you have to do the same for Cutler.
Also, why is having a good team around you a knock? You're insane if you think Cutler is in the same class as Schaub or even Romo for that matter. He's in that 10-15 range, IMO.
Consider the corner turned.....
7 ints all, year. It would be akin to Brees though. A healthy amount of picks.
For all intensive purposes if ability outside the pocket seperates Brady and Rodgers, why cant ability outside the pocket and pocket presance seperate Cutler from Rivers Eli and Schaub?
Also Eli makes ******ed throws he cant make... Cutler makes throws he can make, but shouldnt throw.