lawdog1
Supporter
- Sep 14, 2000
- 60,156
- 72,648
In some cases yes. Most cases no.
With Kevin he literally strained his calf so badly that he was out over a month and hadn’t even practiced. I ain’t no doctor but the calf is connected to the Achilles. Badly compromised calf = chance of Achilles rupture in strenuous activity
Agree.
That said, I think there’s very little chance any of the doctors he was dealing with are going to face any malpractice liability for various reasons. First, to give an assessment, the doctors would have had to rely heavily on what KD was telling them about how his leg felt to him. If he told them he was feeling completely normal, no pain or tightness in the calf or Achilles of any kind and he wasn’t limping, would be hard to say they were negligent in telling him he could play. Second, at the end of the day, it was KD who chose to play in an NBA game, an activity in which injury is always a risk. A lot of doctors will tell you that if an Achilles is going to blow, its going to blow. Doesn’t matter what the person does, it will happen eventually. Unless the doctors involved said, “KD, there is absolutely zero chance you can get hurt in any way if you play in Game 5,” I don’t see a viable malpractice case in this situation.