Is Emmit Smith TRUELY the greatest back in NFL history?

Originally Posted by JD214

Originally Posted by Essential1

He's top 5.... I have him 3rd or 4th..
 




I'd believe 1st or 2nd, but 3rd or 4th? Not sure if serious.

It's either Emmitt or Barry.

Yes Serious.. I got nothing against him, I am not downgrading him for some sort of hatred he is one of my favorite players and I am a Cowboys fan..

1. Barry Sanders
2. Jim Brown
3. Emmitt Smith
4. Walter Payton

and Jim Brown is not light years ahead of him.... He barely beats him for #2... So as time goes on it may switch.. It may not...
 
Originally Posted by JD214

Originally Posted by Essential1

He's top 5.... I have him 3rd or 4th..
 




I'd believe 1st or 2nd, but 3rd or 4th? Not sure if serious.

It's either Emmitt or Barry.

Yes Serious.. I got nothing against him, I am not downgrading him for some sort of hatred he is one of my favorite players and I am a Cowboys fan..

1. Barry Sanders
2. Jim Brown
3. Emmitt Smith
4. Walter Payton

and Jim Brown is not light years ahead of him.... He barely beats him for #2... So as time goes on it may switch.. It may not...
 
Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by dreClark

Chris Johnson.

QFT

Dude has had the greatest first two years of all-time. 
As the greatest EVER in NFL History?  That is just ridiculous

Do you know how many Running Backs in history have had 2 great years..

and his rookie season was good but not great.
 
Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by dreClark

Chris Johnson.

QFT

Dude has had the greatest first two years of all-time. 
As the greatest EVER in NFL History?  That is just ridiculous

Do you know how many Running Backs in history have had 2 great years..

and his rookie season was good but not great.
 
Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by dreClark

Chris Johnson.

QFT

Dude has had the greatest first two years of all-time. 
As the greatest EVER in NFL History?  That is just ridiculous

Do you know how many Running Backs in history have had 2 great years..

and his rookie season was good but not great.
http://niketalk.com/topic/262300?page=1

roll.gif
roll.gif
roll.gif
 
Barry Sanders had no O-line & there were no other options on offense except for him. Emmitt had two other HOF'ers playin on the same side of the ball and played more seasons. He's one of the greatest but I dont think anybody was better than Barry.
 
Barry Sanders had no O-line & there were no other options on offense except for him. Emmitt had two other HOF'ers playin on the same side of the ball and played more seasons. He's one of the greatest but I dont think anybody was better than Barry.
 
Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by dreClark

Chris Johnson.

QFT

Dude has had the greatest first two years of all-time. 
As the greatest EVER in NFL History?  That is just ridiculous

Do you know how many Running Backs in history have had 2 great years..

and his rookie season was good but not great.
http://niketalk.com/topic/262300?page=1

roll.gif
roll.gif
roll.gif
If that is to show sarcasm to reference another thread where someone said something ridiculous... Your sarcasm sucks..

Because I know that dreClark said he doesn't.... Your's is just an argument that the OP of that thread said.. And I didn't see you post in there...

So it's up to interpretation.. And since I can't read a tone of voice through words I have to take words at face value
 
Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by dreClark

Chris Johnson.

QFT

Dude has had the greatest first two years of all-time. 
As the greatest EVER in NFL History?  That is just ridiculous

Do you know how many Running Backs in history have had 2 great years..

and his rookie season was good but not great.
http://niketalk.com/topic/262300?page=1

roll.gif
roll.gif
roll.gif
If that is to show sarcasm to reference another thread where someone said something ridiculous... Your sarcasm sucks..

Because I know that dreClark said he doesn't.... Your's is just an argument that the OP of that thread said.. And I didn't see you post in there...

So it's up to interpretation.. And since I can't read a tone of voice through words I have to take words at face value
 
Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by dreClark

Chris Johnson.

QFT

Dude has had the greatest first two years of all-time. 
As the greatest EVER in NFL History?  That is just ridiculous

Do you know how many Running Backs in history have had 2 great years..

and his rookie season was good but not great.
http://niketalk.com/topic/262300?page=1

roll.gif
roll.gif
roll.gif
If that is to show sarcasm to reference another thread where someone said something ridiculous... Your sarcasm sucks..

  welcome to my life
 
Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by aepps20

Originally Posted by dreClark

Chris Johnson.

QFT

Dude has had the greatest first two years of all-time. 
As the greatest EVER in NFL History?  That is just ridiculous

Do you know how many Running Backs in history have had 2 great years..

and his rookie season was good but not great.
http://niketalk.com/topic/262300?page=1

roll.gif
roll.gif
roll.gif
If that is to show sarcasm to reference another thread where someone said something ridiculous... Your sarcasm sucks..

  welcome to my life
 
Originally Posted by ShaunHillFTW49


  welcome to my life

Well you strike me as a sarcastic human being... Lol........  Damn lib... With your books with no pictures that you read...........
 
Originally Posted by ShaunHillFTW49


  welcome to my life

Well you strike me as a sarcastic human being... Lol........  Damn lib... With your books with no pictures that you read...........
 
Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by ShaunHillFTW49


  welcome to my life

Well you strike me as a sarcastic human being... Lol........  Damn lib... With your books with no pictures that you read...........
Upside   "Pet Goat">  Noam Chomsky
pimp.gif
 
Originally Posted by Essential1

Originally Posted by ShaunHillFTW49


  welcome to my life

Well you strike me as a sarcastic human being... Lol........  Damn lib... With your books with no pictures that you read...........
Upside   "Pet Goat">  Noam Chomsky
pimp.gif
 
IF you're going to already throw Chris Johnson into the ring, then put Terrell Davis in there as well. Not a big enough sample size right? Same for CJ.


Barry is the GOAT, 'nuff said.
 
IF you're going to already throw Chris Johnson into the ring, then put Terrell Davis in there as well. Not a big enough sample size right? Same for CJ.


Barry is the GOAT, 'nuff said.
 
Back
Top Bottom