- Dec 30, 2007
- 1,501
- 10
Originally Posted by Epidemik The Great
yesOriginally Posted by Not a sneak
Originally Posted by LIVE BOY D
what the #%$@ is wrong with you people throwing the word classic around? kanye west has 2 good albums and 1 very good one. ONLY classic between these 2 is Marshall Mathers LPOriginally Posted by Epidemik The Great
i'm not talking sale-wise, Em has that in a bag...but quality wise...nahhh...Ye has 3 classics under his belt and changed the game up every time around...Em has been re-hashing the same **@# for the past 10 years plus a couple of not too impressive to flat out wack albums under his beltOriginally Posted by Chao
Originally Posted by millionuppercuts
Quality or Sales, Eminem wins either way. I'm actually glad FOR ONCE the best rapper sold the most. In this lollipop DIY Hip Hop era it's surprising...it shows you that if you make quality *@$+, sooner or later people will start buying. We gonna act like EM was a multi-million selling artist from the get go?Originally Posted by Epidemik The Great
Originally Posted by Chao
Originally Posted by Cobra Kai
Kanye should have gotten it. But it's based off of sales and not actually quality. *kanye shrug* and I'm out...
Don't really think Kanye's body of work matches up to Ems either way.
huh????
Yeah, exactly. I thought my point was pretty clear from the first post anyway - Kanye's three albums that can actually be considered within the Hip Hop genre don't stack up with Eminems catalogue in quality or in sales. Also, million, yeah, I think people forget how much he had to fight in the underground before he finally hooked up with Dre and started selling. Best rapper ever, nah, I wouldn't support that, but Soundscan artist of the decade doesn't seem like a stretch at all.
Sorry I'm so late but did my man just say Graduation was a classic? Only thing you could put an argument for is College Dropout and thats not even a classic in any means. You gonna seriously say CD, LR, Graduation and 808&HB is better then MMLP SSLP Infinite ES and relapse(i'm forgetting one i'm dumb tired)? You're just as dumb as the guy who said "its funny white people are representing hiphop" when the award has nothing to do with hiphop music.
so all of a sudden i'm "dumb" because i have an independent opinion??? stan much??? like i said, Kanye changed the game every time he came out from his production style to his personal style...Eminem's STILL re-hashing his same topics...
I love Kanye and Em so no stan here, how did Kanye change the game? Kanye didn't change anything he is just very good at what he does, which is make music; creatively. You gonna throw Graduation up with the ranks of Ready to Die, Doggy style, Me against the World, The Fix, The Chronic, Low End Theory, Reasonable Doubt, 36 Chambers, It takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back, and Illmatic? Those are CLASSICs HANDS DOWN. For you to throw Graduation and 808s in there as classics is stan like. When in actuallity it was em who broke down the doors for white people in hip hop. Em took light weight horror rap(a very shunned rap category) and made it main stream, along with coming with heart felt songs, and making songs that had political opinions. Saying Eminem is re-hashing old the same topics Kanye raps about the same %@#% most of the time, money, clothes and *#$@, with the sporadic different topic song. Kanye is a wonderful talent and a great musician, but to say artist of the decade above Em, Hov, and Nas and countless other genres of music is foolsih.