- 281
- 19
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2005
I'll take Penny. He was so versatile. Scottie Pippen could guard anybody but the 2 players he always had trouble guarding were Penny and Kobe. They just had too many moves.
Anfernee Hardaway or Tracy McGrady Vol. #1 in Orlando
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by flyest in the hood,
- Start date
- 281
- 19
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2005
I'll take Penny. He was so versatile. Scottie Pippen could guard anybody but the 2 players he always had trouble guarding were Penny and Kobe. They just had too many moves.
D
Deleted member 38182
Guest
Originally Posted by hella handsome
Jordan
Kobe
Penny
T-Mac
Wade
Best shooting guards to play the game imo in that order. So based off that list, Penny > Tmac to me, BUT he damn sure isn't that far down from penny.
If Wade gets his damn team together, he can be near the top of that list though
- 20,201
- 4,184
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2007
I never got hype around Penny, he was a great player but he had a great team with Shaq which cant be underestimated. In my opinion Penny was a top 10 player in the leauge when he played but he wasnt elite
Jordan
Malone
Hakeem
Robinson
Payton
Shaq
Penny or Pippen
When T-Mac played for the Magic prime he was definitely a elite player. The list was something like this
Shaq
Duncan
Kobe
McGrady
Garnett
With Kidd, AI and Webber being mentioned as right on the cusp. And Yes, McGrady was at the same level as Kobe for a couple of years.
Jordan
Malone
Hakeem
Robinson
Payton
Shaq
Penny or Pippen
When T-Mac played for the Magic prime he was definitely a elite player. The list was something like this
Shaq
Duncan
Kobe
McGrady
Garnett
With Kidd, AI and Webber being mentioned as right on the cusp. And Yes, McGrady was at the same level as Kobe for a couple of years.
- 20,201
- 4,184
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2007
I never got hype around Penny, he was a great player but he had a great team with Shaq which cant be underestimated. In my opinion Penny was a top 10 player in the leauge when he played but he wasnt elite
Jordan
Malone
Hakeem
Robinson
Payton
Shaq
Penny or Pippen
When T-Mac played for the Magic prime he was definitely a elite player. The list was something like this
Shaq
Duncan
Kobe
McGrady
Garnett
With Kidd, AI and Webber being mentioned as right on the cusp. And Yes, McGrady was at the same level as Kobe for a couple of years.
Jordan
Malone
Hakeem
Robinson
Payton
Shaq
Penny or Pippen
When T-Mac played for the Magic prime he was definitely a elite player. The list was something like this
Shaq
Duncan
Kobe
McGrady
Garnett
With Kidd, AI and Webber being mentioned as right on the cusp. And Yes, McGrady was at the same level as Kobe for a couple of years.
- 8,332
- 216
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2011
^Barkley??? Ewing??? Stockton??? Grant Hill even???
- 8,332
- 216
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2011
^Barkley??? Ewing??? Stockton??? Grant Hill even???
- 442
- 11
- Joined
- May 10, 2009
Wow ive officially heard it all now, '' Penny wasnt elite '' you gotta be %^#!@#% kiddin me....
Then you go and put AI and Kidd on the cusp when they both made it to the finals with mediocre squads and AI even got MVP
And im so sick of this doing less with more angle thats been running rampant on NT, especially in this case when its clearly a double standard because both Kidd and AI took there teams far while not having much talent. So if T-Mac couldnt get outta the 1st round why shouldnt that be held against him?
As far as players go i gotta go with Penny all day, yes T-Mac had the obvious edge in scoring but thats where his edge stops. Penny was more versatile and he was no slouch on the scoring end either.
- 442
- 11
- Joined
- May 10, 2009
Wow ive officially heard it all now, '' Penny wasnt elite '' you gotta be %^#!@#% kiddin me....
Then you go and put AI and Kidd on the cusp when they both made it to the finals with mediocre squads and AI even got MVP
And im so sick of this doing less with more angle thats been running rampant on NT, especially in this case when its clearly a double standard because both Kidd and AI took there teams far while not having much talent. So if T-Mac couldnt get outta the 1st round why shouldnt that be held against him?
As far as players go i gotta go with Penny all day, yes T-Mac had the obvious edge in scoring but thats where his edge stops. Penny was more versatile and he was no slouch on the scoring end either.
- 28,112
- 2,660
- Joined
- Dec 21, 2002
Penny.
- 28,112
- 2,660
- Joined
- Dec 21, 2002
Penny.
- 2,099
- 12
- Joined
- Nov 23, 2009
T-Mac
- 2,099
- 12
- Joined
- Nov 23, 2009
T-Mac
- 20,201
- 4,184
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2007
Nope during Penny's best magic years.....95-97
Barkley was still great but his elite years were 88-95. Malone had overtaken him as best PF by then
Ewing was great but he was 3 rd best center by then. Stockton was awesome too but he was really regared as a top 5 player in the leauge. he never got MVP consideration in my recollection. Grant Hill was right at the cusp to me but his teams werent good. Penny was better than him at that point.
Look man if you did a top 5-10 list right now everybodys list would be different. This my list.
- 20,201
- 4,184
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2007
Nope during Penny's best magic years.....95-97
Barkley was still great but his elite years were 88-95. Malone had overtaken him as best PF by then
Ewing was great but he was 3 rd best center by then. Stockton was awesome too but he was really regared as a top 5 player in the leauge. he never got MVP consideration in my recollection. Grant Hill was right at the cusp to me but his teams werent good. Penny was better than him at that point.
Look man if you did a top 5-10 list right now everybodys list would be different. This my list.
- 1,076
- 367
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2001
I hated penny and that magic team when I was young because they knocked the bulls out of the playoffs in 95 and when we moved to Orlando from Chicago around the time tmac signed with them I liked mcgrady a lot, went to plenty of games at amway or the td waterhouse with the $10 upper bowl seats, but tmac just could not get it done in the playoffs, and any one will tell you that the playoffs are the only thing that matters, that being said ill go with penny
- 1,076
- 367
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2001
I hated penny and that magic team when I was young because they knocked the bulls out of the playoffs in 95 and when we moved to Orlando from Chicago around the time tmac signed with them I liked mcgrady a lot, went to plenty of games at amway or the td waterhouse with the $10 upper bowl seats, but tmac just could not get it done in the playoffs, and any one will tell you that the playoffs are the only thing that matters, that being said ill go with penny
- 2,026
- 11
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2011
^T-Mac couldn't get it done in the playoffs? You sure it wasn't his teammates?
- 2,026
- 11
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2011
^T-Mac couldn't get it done in the playoffs? You sure it wasn't his teammates?
- 1,417
- 71
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2005
- 1,417
- 71
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2005
- 1,519
- 256
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2008
I'm old school. I say Penny as a MAGIC. As an overall player, its T-Mac.
However, although Penny's stats don't stack up quite as high, he still did it as #2 with Shaq on the floor.
As far as footwear goes...still Penny.
However, although Penny's stats don't stack up quite as high, he still did it as #2 with Shaq on the floor.
As far as footwear goes...still Penny.
- 1,519
- 256
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2008
I'm old school. I say Penny as a MAGIC. As an overall player, its T-Mac.
However, although Penny's stats don't stack up quite as high, he still did it as #2 with Shaq on the floor.
As far as footwear goes...still Penny.
However, although Penny's stats don't stack up quite as high, he still did it as #2 with Shaq on the floor.
As far as footwear goes...still Penny.
- 5,456
- 11
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2008
T-Mac is one of the few players in the history of the league to actually have a better stats in the playoffs than the regular season. To say he (alone) couldn't get it done is buffoonery.
Didn't even bring up defense. But then I'll get attacked with no heart prob.
Didn't even bring up defense. But then I'll get attacked with no heart prob.
- 5,456
- 11
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2008
T-Mac is one of the few players in the history of the league to actually have a better stats in the playoffs than the regular season. To say he (alone) couldn't get it done is buffoonery.
Didn't even bring up defense. But then I'll get attacked with no heart prob.
Didn't even bring up defense. But then I'll get attacked with no heart prob.
