Emoni Bates, 6-8 forward, Bates Fundamentals
Needless to say, Bates was at the very top of my list of guys I wanted to see. I understand that the people who rank him so high and speak so well of his game have seen him a lot more than I have, and there’s a reason he was named Gatorade National Player of the Year as a sophomore. Still, I came away rather underwhelmed. Bates had an awesome game the night before I arrived, but he was really bad during the game I saw on Friday. He was uninterested, uninvolved, and he took a lot of awful shots. Bates ended up making 6-of-16 from the floor as his team lost by 20 points. Many of the coaches I was sitting with were also seeing him for the first time and had the same reaction. On the other hand, a veteran scout whom I respect simply shrugged. He insisted Bates was the real thing. “Sometimes the bad shots go in, sometimes they don’t,” he said.
Bates did play better the next two games — he made some of those tough shots, including a ridiculous fallaway 3-pointer from deep in the corner — but I still saw a lot of deficiencies. He is very slightly built, and for long stretches he seemed unengaged. Like a lot of players at this stage, Bates has little understanding of how to impact a game when he doesn’t have the ball. His best asset is his ballhandling, and when he is determined enough he can get to the rim almost anytime he wants. I wouldn’t say he’s great at finishing over size, but it’s impossible for defenders to stay in front of him. His defense wasn’t bad — it was nonexistent. On several occasions, I saw him try to defend a fast break that ended in a dunk.
It’s easy to see Bates’ potential. He is tall, long, and during flashes he shows an array of offensive skills. But the general consensus amongst coaches and scouts I talked to is that, while Bates hasn’t exactly regressed over the last year or two, he has not made the progress they expected. He was recently bumped down to No. 2 in the 247Sports composite rankings for the Class of 2022. That’s still very high, obviously, but it’s also a sign that things are not moving in a good direction. As has been well-documented, Bates attends a school in Michigan that was started by his family. His father, E.J., keeps his circle extremely tight — so tight, in fact, that he doesn’t like outside coaches and trainers to work with Emoni. So it’s fair to ask whether not being in a traditional school or a powerhouse prep program is hurting Bates’ progress. Time will tell.
Another thing I noticed about Bates is that you didn’t see a whole lot of big-name coaches at his games. That’s because nobody thinks he will spend a minute in college. He will most likely end up in the NBA G League, where he will get first-rate coaching, training and competitive exposure. It will be interesting to see how ready he is.