2013-2014 NBA Thread - IND @ WAS and OKC @ LAC on ESPN

Status
Not open for further replies.
This convo on First Take...


I'm agreeing with Skip on the whole "Super Star" thing..
 
what did skip say on first take?

we dont get it in canada 
mean.gif
 
what did skip say on first take?


we dont get it in canada :{

CP3, Durant, Melo, and a bunch of other guys don't deserve the "super star" title and to be discussed on the same realm as guys who transcended to the next level like Kobe, Duncan, MJ, Shaq, Wade, etc.

That hardware is really what separates the men from the boys. I do personally feel like the "SUPERSTAR" thing is a marketing tactic to boost the value of these players to sell tickets and merchandise.


Because imo KD is a star, a great player. But Lebron is a superstar. That ring solidified him being SUPER.


Its all about that hardware.
 
CP3 might be a better PG but he's not a better player than Steph.

This tiny thing called defense, means that he is without question.

People are too much, one game and everyone loses their minds, Chris Paul when healthy is the the third best player in the league, none else particularly close either. Thats what happens when you are elite on both sides of th ball.
 
 
what did skip say on first take?


we dont get it in canada 
mean.gif
CP3, Durant, Melo, and a bunch of other guys don't deserve the "super star" title and to be discussed on the same realm as guys who transcended to the next level like Kobe, Duncan, MJ, Shaq, Wade, etc.

That hardware is really what separates the men from the boys. I do personally feel like the "SUPERSTAR" thing is a marketing tactic to boost the value of these players to sell tickets and merchandise.


Because imo KD is a star, a great player. But Lebron is a superstar. That ring solidified him being SUPER.


Its all about that hardware.
yeah, i agree with this. earlier in this thread i already said that KD isnt a superstar yet because hes only 25 and has yet to win a ring. 

of course it all comes down to how you define a superstar and having a different definition doesnt mean you're wrong
 
 
CP3 might be a better PG but he's not a better player than Steph.
This tiny thing called defense, means that he is without question.

People are too much, one game and everyone loses their minds, Chris Paul when healthy is the the third best player in the league, none else particularly close either. Thats what happens when you are elite on both sides of th ball.
one game? 
laugh.gif


how about every year for the past decade? who cares if you're considered the third best player in the league when you are not good enough to ever win a ring. but i guess he just needs better teammates
 
"@ESPNStatsInfo: Kevin Durant has 1,579 pts in 55 career playoff games. LeBron James scored 1,579 pts in his 1st 55 playoff games (via @EliasSports )"
 
This tiny thing called defense, means that he is without question.

People are too much, one game and everyone loses their minds, Chris Paul when healthy is the the third best player in the league, none else particularly close either. Thats what happens when you are elite on both sides of th ball.

PG defense is minimally important thought, no one lauds that point more than anyone than you when you spent years pimping Nash.

Steph changes the game in a way that CP3 hasn't since his knee injuries. He has to be covered from 30 feet out and changes the way teams play defense.

The PG position is just not that important when your playing with the best players in the world. Good passing comes from 5 guys moving the ball not one of them orchestrating the movement independently. If you can't go out and score 30 for a series, your not to be the guy on a playoff team.
 
The PG position is just not that important when your playing with the best players in the world. Good passing comes from 5 guys moving the ball not one of them orchestrating the movement independently. If you can't go out and score 30 for a series, your not to be the guy on a playoff team.
pretty much. theres no rule in basketball that forces the shortest guy on the court to dribble the ball a lot and run the offence

ill take mj, kobe, lebron, wade running the offense as my "pg" 10 out of 10 times over cp3 or any pg in nba history other than magic who was pretty much lebron sized.
 
Durant is one of the greatest players ever and this "regular" star vs. superstar thing is so foolish.

I really don't think its foolish. I really think it comes down to who ultimately gets the job done at the end of the post season.


As great as Charles Barkley is, you know the difference between him and MJ. Between Patrick Ewing and Kareem.


I really think people give these guys who haven't achieved the ultimate goal too much credit in comparison to the guys that have.


Favorites aside. IMO you can't put Wolverine on the same level as Superman until he saves the world, b.


People are trying really hard nowadays to discredit the value of winning titles. Giving players just as much, if not more credit than the guys who play just as many games and ultimately, get the job done. KD is not on Lebrons level at the end of the day for that exact reason. And thats the difference between a star and a superstar.
 
Last edited:
Skip bayless said the heat got lucky to wn game 1. Still don't think he's a troll?

Serious question here:

Al Jefferson took shots in the locker room during the game, I assume of cortisone, why isn't that considered a PED?
 
Skip bayless said the heat got lucky to wn game 1. Still don't think he's a troll?

Serious question here:

Al Jefferson took shots in the locker room during the game, I assume of cortisone, why isn't that considered a PED?
i'm thinking it's a medical treatment that does not enhance performance

it also varies by sport. isn't cortisone banned in cycling?
 
Last edited:
Skip bayless said the heat got lucky to wn game 1. Still don't think he's a troll?

Serious question here:

Al Jefferson took shots in the locker room during the game, I assume of cortisone, why isn't that considered a PED?
i'm thinking it's a medical treatment that does not enhance performance

It's like a painkiller players use to play through pain that without they might not be able to play though.
 
Off Topic - The Pacquiao/Mayweather argument on First Take right now :rollin


"FLOYD AIN'T KNOCKING OUT NO-TING! HE DOESN'T EVEN HIT THE BAG HARD. HE HITS THE BAG LIKE THIS!" :lol
 
This convo on First Take...


I'm agreeing with Skip on the whole "Super Star" thing..

That's why I brought it up this morning. Skip may troll but his points and argument about Paul and what a superstar is this morning was valid regardless if you like him or not. You don't have to agree but can't flat out dismiss it as outrageous either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom