- 1,179
- 23
- Joined
- Nov 21, 2008
I think when its said and done Peyton will be #1..
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: this_feature_currently_requires_accessing_site_using_safari
Thank you, I came in to say the exact same thing.Originally Posted by dmncn lew
The year the Colts won the Super Bowl he threw 3 touchdowns and 8 interceptions in the playoffs. Not to mention the numerous first round exits. On a side note, Joe Montana played in 4 super Bowls and NEVER threw an interception!
IMO the comparison between peyton and brady is similar to steve young and troy aikman. Both teams put the QBs in place to win games, but in thebrady/manning debate manning has put up better numbers. Similarly steve young may have won less sb's than aikman but steve had much better stats.Originally Posted by DubA169
you don't think peyton can do better with crap surrounding him than brady??
Originally Posted by Carlos Tevez
Thank you, I came in to say the exact same thing.Originally Posted by dmncn lew
The year the Colts won the Super Bowl he threw 3 touchdowns and 8 interceptions in the playoffs. Not to mention the numerous first round exits. On a side note, Joe Montana played in 4 super Bowls and NEVER threw an interception!
The same Peyton Manning that chokes every year in the playoffs?
The same Peyton Manning that won Super Bowl MVP for throwing only 3 TDs and 8 INTs (1 TD and 1 INT in the SB) in 4 playoff games that year?
Dont tell me this crap that Manning never had a defense. The Colts have been solid defensively for most of the years Manning has been there. Without his D, they wouldn't have won the SB in 07.
Brady > Manning among this generation of QBs. 3 SB Rings > 1 SB Ring. 14-3 career playoff record > 7-8 playoff record
Originally Posted by shatterkneesinc
peyton can make any wr look good but you cant say that about brady
Originally Posted by Carlos Tevez
Thank you, I came in to say the exact same thing.Originally Posted by dmncn lew
The year the Colts won the Super Bowl he threw 3 touchdowns and 8 interceptions in the playoffs. Not to mention the numerous first round exits. On a side note, Joe Montana played in 4 super Bowls and NEVER threw an interception!
The same Peyton Manning that watches the rest of his team choke every year in the playoffs?
The same Peyton Manning that won Super Bowl MVP for throwing only 3 TDs and 8 INTs (1 TD and 1 INT in the SB) in 4 playoff games that year?
Dont tell me this crap that Manning never had a defense. The Colts have been below average most of the years Manning has been there. Without Rex Grossman.
Brady < Manning
Brady = product of a system
Manning = manipulator of Defense's
Are you kidding? Tom Brady won titles with these guys as his WRs...Originally Posted by shatterkneesinc
peyton can make any wr look good but you cant say that about brady
Originally Posted by Let Me Post
possibly...easily top 5...
Originally Posted by LilStarZ07
imagine peyton manning on youngs or montanas 49er teams ... ... ... ... ... ... smh
> ______
Originally Posted by BalconyBundles
Originally Posted by LilStarZ07
imagine peyton manning on youngs or montanas 49er teams ... ... ... ... ... ... smh
> ______
looks at screen name
you have lost all credibility on here
I will say a case can be argued for Manning, but i still think Joe Montana is/was better