it's rarely if ever solely based on straight scent. Typically the aroma is just the icing on the cake. Your appearance is the largest factor on if you get compliments or not, and the mention of how good you smell is just the cue to break the ice. I get compliments all of the time, but at the end of the day, I'm a pretty good looking guy, I've been blessed with nice facial features, great teeth and I'm super active and athletic, so my body is on point, so I'm sure those factors play the biggest part in if women approach me or not. And then I do the other things, I dress well, I present myself respectfully and I just try and keep an approachable demeanor, you'd be surprised how much more attention you receive if you just make the effort to smile more. Give it a try. All of you, give it a try if you aren't getting the attention you want from the ones you want.