Yeah I've been harsh on him too. Eddie has the tools to succeed in a system where he's a target man and doesn't need to create for himself from midfield. Same problem Laca had. He's been wasteful overall, which is crazy to say because he has been having a moderately successful season all things considered, but Arteta's system hasn't been working well for him or the team. He looks lost in buildup too often and can't make the right pass or run.
But when he's in front of the ball, back to the goal, he's got some magic in his feet (even if it doesn't result in a goal). Balogun is really going to give him a test next year.