- May 1, 2011
- 37,687
- 32,027
Rosen's first year wasn't better than both of their first years as starters, though... Barkley's team finished with a better record his freshman year and career wise, do you think Rosen will ever have a season like Barkley's Junior year? Feel free to project that if you want...
And I think you don't remember John David Booty well...
Yes, i can safely think Rosen will have a better year than Barkleys junior year. But i can't predict his winning record though. He can't do it all by himself. What USC QB has? Name one very good USC QB that didn't have the supporting cast around him? Rosen will be winning the Heisman (or be in the top 3) his junior year. You bring up Barkley was winning more his freshmen year, YES, no doubt. But come on, that team was solid with a great head coach. He won 9 games. Rosen won 8. We're splitting hairs here. Is that the measurement of talent? Barkley won 7 games his senior year with Lee and Woods as his receivers. We forgetting about that?
Remember, my comment stemmed from me saying Rosen will be the most talented QB he's ever worked with. Lets not forget.
Of course I remember JDB. What do you mean? Lets not forget the teams he had. He had some great players around him. He wasn't the reason they were winning 11 games. Just a piece.
Goff won 8 games at Cal. Should we say JDB was better than him.
We're going off topic here. Lets not forget the reason why we're even debating this.
and yes, ROsens freshmen year was better than Barkleys. Are we serious here? Barkley threw 15 td's and 14 picks for 2700 yards. You know ROsens stats. But because he won one more game, he had a better freshmen year?
Last edited: