Official 2011 San Francisco Giants Season Thread (86-76) 2nd Place in NL West

Originally Posted by FRANCHISE 55

Serious question: Does Orlando Cepeda deserve to have a statue?
Rookie of the Year
10x All Star with the Giants

On second thought, I don't know. It's kind of iffy. FRANCHISE pointed out some flaws with his awards.
 
Originally Posted by FRANCHISE 55

Serious question: Does Orlando Cepeda deserve to have a statue?
Rookie of the Year
10x All Star with the Giants

On second thought, I don't know. It's kind of iffy. FRANCHISE pointed out some flaws with his awards.
 
He only played nine seasons with the Giants though. The World Series wasn't with the Giants, and the MVP wasn't with the Giants.
 
He only played nine seasons with the Giants though. The World Series wasn't with the Giants, and the MVP wasn't with the Giants.
 
Originally Posted by FRANCHISE 55

He only played nine seasons with the Giants though. The World Series wasn't with the Giants, and the MVP wasn't with the Giants.
I realized that and I changed it.
 
Originally Posted by FRANCHISE 55

He only played nine seasons with the Giants though. The World Series wasn't with the Giants, and the MVP wasn't with the Giants.
I realized that and I changed it.
 
And he only made six All Star teams with the Giants, not 10.

I'm not denying that he's a Hall of Famer, but I just question if he did enough with the Giants to warrant a statue.
 
And he only made six All Star teams with the Giants, not 10.

I'm not denying that he's a Hall of Famer, but I just question if he did enough with the Giants to warrant a statue.
 
Cain starting the 2-out rally
pimp.gif
 
Yeah on Wikipedia, they had an all star game in Pittsburgh and in Los Angeles in 1959. I don't know about that either back in the day. I was confused when I counted the all star appearances for Cepeda.
 
Yeah on Wikipedia, they had an all star game in Pittsburgh and in Los Angeles in 1959. I don't know about that either back in the day. I was confused when I counted the all star appearances for Cepeda.
 
So with a ROY, 10 All-Star appearances (but only in 6 different seasons), 226 home runs, 767 RBI, and .308 average in a Giants uniform, he deserves to have a statue in front of AT&T Park?

In my opinion, that doesn't seen statue worthy. If he had a profound influence off the field or had a bigger historical impact on the Giants than his statistics and accolades show, I'm open to changing my opinion. 
laugh.gif
 
So with a ROY, 10 All-Star appearances (but only in 6 different seasons), 226 home runs, 767 RBI, and .308 average in a Giants uniform, he deserves to have a statue in front of AT&T Park?

In my opinion, that doesn't seen statue worthy. If he had a profound influence off the field or had a bigger historical impact on the Giants than his statistics and accolades show, I'm open to changing my opinion. 
laugh.gif
 
Tejada is going to %+@@ this up
mad.gif


laugh.gif
Glad to see Tejada make me eat my words but he still sucks
 
Tejada is going to %+@@ this up
mad.gif


laugh.gif
Glad to see Tejada make me eat my words but he still sucks
 
This %*$$%*% piece of #@++ DeRosa. Out for the season. Bank it. Get a real baseball player up here please!!!!!
 
This %*$$%*% piece of #@++ DeRosa. Out for the season. Bank it. Get a real baseball player up here please!!!!!
 
Back
Top Bottom