NT MLB Experts, I have a Quick Question..

[rocky437]

Bottom 9, 2 out, Runner on 3rd, tie game. 
The guy hits the ball to shortstop, he bobbles it, the runner on third gets to home plate safely, but the shortstop still manages to throw out the runner on first to get the third out. 

We going to extra innings? Or is it game over? 

 

[nooera]

If dude gets to home plate before the ball gets to first base game then its game over.

Right?

I think

 

[doublejs07]

Extra innings.

 

[rocky437]

Originally Posted by NooEra

If dude gets to home plate before the ball gets to first base game then its game over.

Right?

I think

But what if it was a flyball to the outfield? Using that logic the runner on third could touch home before the ball lands in the outfielders glove and it would count, so that cant be right. 

 

[pdouly33]

Extra innings. The run would not count.

 

[kevin cleveland]

Originally Posted by DoubleJs07

Extra innings.

 

[irie]

I think its all because of the bobble. As in he's charged with an error. You cant beat a forceout that is done in a "continuous" motion. So because of the bobble the run counts
edit - thats why i aint no ump

 

[rocky437]

Originally Posted by irie

I think its all because of the bobble. As in he's charged with an error. You cant beat a forceout that is done in a "continuous" motion. So because of the bobble the run counts
edit - thats why i aint no ump

Lol indeed. 

 

[rrroth]

Game over, run doesn't score because the force out at 1B was the third out of the inning.

 

[rocky437]

Originally Posted by rrroth

Game over, run doesn't score because the force out at 1B was the third out of the inning.

you mean extra innings then

 

[dland24]

This isnt a question a baseball "expert" would need to answer. The run does not count.

 

[rrroth]

I didn't have my reading glasses on.. My bad.

 

[Bend_The_Knee]

Originally Posted by dland24

This isnt a question a baseball "expert" would need to answer. The run does not count.

 

[ooiron manoo]

Originally Posted by irie

I think its all because of the bobble. As in he's charged with an error. You cant beat a forceout that is done in a "continuous" motion. So because of the bobble the run counts
edit - thats why i aint no ump

Sometimes it's best to stop thinking...

 

[DeadsetAce]

Originally Posted by Kevin Cleveland

Originally Posted by DoubleJs07

Extra innings.

 

[oasis]

Extra innings