NT All Time MLB Re-Draft vol: Voting is Open

[macbk]

@finallyfamous great pick. Doc

 

[madj55]

I really wanted Halladay, great pick.

 

[651akathepaul]

Champs pick is in...

 

[CP1708]

No need to keep it a secret......

 

[651akathepaul]

@champcruthik selects Grover Cleveland Alexander, aka "Old Pete."

 

[dland24]

Champ selects "Old Pete" Alexander

 

[dland24]

Ha. Same time.

 

[CP1708]

He's a pitcher, right?

 

[essential1]

We sure he didn’t just pick a president?

 

[651akathepaul]

With that, I will take one of the greatest all-around baseball players of all-time...

Kirrrbbyyy Puckett

CF

 

[dland24]

Yes Grover Cleveland Alexander is a pitcher haha

 

[essential1]

EddieDoyers

@johnnyredstorm you’re on deck

 

[651akathepaul]

He's a pitcher, right?

Yes.

 

[EddieDoyers]

2nd best pitcher in Dodgers history
Don't @ me

 

[essential1]

@johnnyredstorm Your turn

JCMojica24 On Deck

 

[CP1708]

Players off the board:

Spoiler: Round 1

Round 1
Barry Bonds
Willie Mays
Ken Griffey Jr
Pedro Martinez
Cy Young
Babe Ruth
Walter Johnson
Ted Williams
Greg Maddux
Alex Rodriguez
Mike Trout
Roger Clemens
Mickey Mantle
Hank Aaron
Rickey Henderson
Joe DiMaggio
Lou Gehrig
Sandy Koufax
Stan Musial
Dwight Gooden
Randy Johnson
Roberto Clemente
Manny Ramirez
Frank Robinson
Bob Gibson
Mike Schmidt
Honus Wagner
Tom Seaver
Warren Spahn
Johnny Bench

Spoiler: Round 2

Round 2
Albert Pujols
Ty Cobb
Nolan Ryan
Mark McGwire
Ernie Banks
Yogi Berra
Steve Carlton
Tony Gwynn
Cal Ripken Jr
Joe Morgan
Wade Boggs
Rogers Hornsby
Al Kaline
Jackie Robinson
Tris Speaker
Lefty Grove
Jimmie Foxx
Clayton Kershaw
Harmon Killebrew
Mike Piazza
Chipper Jones
Willie McCovey
Curt Schilling
Felix Hernandez
Mel Ott
Bert Blyleven
Adrian Beltre
Gaylord Perry
George Brett

Spoiler: Round 3

Round 3
Phil Niekro
Edgar Martinez
Jose Altuve
Carl Yastrzemski
Jeff Bagwell
Tom Glavine
Max Scherzer
Roy Campanella
David Ortiz
Mike Mussina
John Smoltz
Juan Marichal
Eddie Mathews
Derek Jeter
Ralph Kiner
Pete Rose
Bob Feller
Christy Mathewson
Jim Palmer
Reggie Jackson
Larry Doby
Miguel Cabrera
Frank Thomas
Andy Pettitte
Rod Carew
Ichiro
Brooks Robinson
Hank Greenberg
Ozzie Smith

Round 4
Roberto Alomar
Pudge Rodriguez
Vlad Guerrero
Kris Bryant
Fergie Jenkins
Barry Larkin
Robinson Cano
Sammy Sosa
Roy Halladay
Robin Yount
Rollie Fingers
Grover Alexander
Kirby Puckett
Don Drysdale

20 picks so far today. That's not bad.

 

[macbk]

Can't believe Dirk hasn't posted at all.

 

[JCMojica24]

So mad I lost out on Vlad and Sosa lol.

 

[macbk]

So mad I lost out on Vlad and Sosa lol.

Kris Bryant the reach of the draft thus far. Sorry rck3sactown

 

[651akathepaul]

I had Vlad up there to take with this last pick if things didn't pan out, but I wasn't passing on Kirby at this spot if he was available no matter what. I had two others pegged for my last pick as well that I'm surprised haven't been picked yet.

 

[rck3sactown]

Kris Bryant the reach of the draft thus far. Sorry rck3sactown

God damn it


good to know

 

[dland24]

Kris Bryant the reach of the draft thus far. Sorry rck3sactown

Disagree.

I think my guy Finns has that honor. Dwight Gooden 21st overall?!? Really?

There were only 20 players in the history of the game better than him?

He was drafted ahead of Randy Johnson.

Tom Seaver.

Warren Spahn.

Don Drysdale was the most recent pitcher selected. I could make a legitimate claim that he, a late 3rd round pick, was a better pitcher than Doc.

Sorry Finns. Cant have a major reach in the first round.

 

[EddieDoyers]

Yeah I was surprised Dwight Gooden was taken that early lol
Was thinking he would be a 8th to 10th rounder

 

[DeadsetAce]

doc already went?!! g'damn

must be posters of doc on finnns' wall

 

[essential1]

If you’re picking based on Peak performance, Doc is up there with every name on the list. Doc was honestly on his way to being a Top 5 All Time Pitcher.

I wouldn’t have picked him Round 1, I had him like 5th or 6th. But if you’re drafting on peak performance, he’s worthy of where he was picked.