Is "Midnight Marauders" better than "Illmatic" ?????

electric relaxtion is one the illest beats in hip hop ever...

i did somethin over it bout a month ago...
pimp.gif
 
electric relaxtion is one the illest beats in hip hop ever...

i did somethin over it bout a month ago...
pimp.gif
 
Originally Posted by Ruxxx

Yo...
This is an A+ thread here
pimp.gif

With that said...
I'm gonna have to say no.
I'm not talking about an "AWW HELL NAW!" kind of no either (because I LOVE Tribe and MM is bonkers),but more of an "it's close,but not quite" kind of no (if that makes sense).
Thanks dude
wink.gif

just makes me delighted when people say its very close to Illmatic which goes to show that it is a Great Album
its not messing with Illmatic at all on the lyricism, but its more complete and thoroughly put 2gether
even still, Illmatic is equal to MM, so its sometimes like a flip of a coin to see which is the better album
 
Originally Posted by Ruxxx

Yo...
This is an A+ thread here
pimp.gif

With that said...
I'm gonna have to say no.
I'm not talking about an "AWW HELL NAW!" kind of no either (because I LOVE Tribe and MM is bonkers),but more of an "it's close,but not quite" kind of no (if that makes sense).
Thanks dude
wink.gif

just makes me delighted when people say its very close to Illmatic which goes to show that it is a Great Album
its not messing with Illmatic at all on the lyricism, but its more complete and thoroughly put 2gether
even still, Illmatic is equal to MM, so its sometimes like a flip of a coin to see which is the better album
 
Hard to compare two classic albums. But as far as Midnight Marauders goes I actually like Low End Theory more than that albums. But then once again in that case it's just hard to compare two classic albums. All of them are great and it's a time in Hip-Hop I wish still existed. 
 
Hard to compare two classic albums. But as far as Midnight Marauders goes I actually like Low End Theory more than that albums. But then once again in that case it's just hard to compare two classic albums. All of them are great and it's a time in Hip-Hop I wish still existed. 
 
Originally Posted by mossman75

IMO Midnight Marauders is the better album, its more entertaining

QFT.

And while we are on the subject, whats everyone's opinion on the better album between MM and Low End Theory
nerd.gif
.......
 
Originally Posted by mossman75

IMO Midnight Marauders is the better album, its more entertaining

QFT.

And while we are on the subject, whats everyone's opinion on the better album between MM and Low End Theory
nerd.gif
.......
 
Originally Posted by GL Rayner

Originally Posted by mossman75

IMO Midnight Marauders is the better album, its more entertaining

QFT.

And while we are on the subject, whats everyone's opinion on the better album between MM and Low End Theory
nerd.gif
.......
MM over Low End Theory for me.....although Jazz (we've got) gets rotated heavily as well as a few other cuts 
 
Originally Posted by GL Rayner

Originally Posted by mossman75

IMO Midnight Marauders is the better album, its more entertaining

QFT.

And while we are on the subject, whats everyone's opinion on the better album between MM and Low End Theory
nerd.gif
.......
MM over Low End Theory for me.....although Jazz (we've got) gets rotated heavily as well as a few other cuts 
 
Unlike most album comparison threads, this is actually a good one.  With that being said, I still would go with Illmatic though, it truly set the bar for alot of albums that came after it.  I can see how and why some folks would like MM more.  Illmatic is just pure perfection and is a perfect display of what hip hop is all about. 
 
Unlike most album comparison threads, this is actually a good one.  With that being said, I still would go with Illmatic though, it truly set the bar for alot of albums that came after it.  I can see how and why some folks would like MM more.  Illmatic is just pure perfection and is a perfect display of what hip hop is all about. 
 
Finally I thread worth talking about in the music forum. This is such a hard question but a good one. And on that note I'll have to push. I can literally know each and every verse on both albums. I live these two albums here. MM IMO created jazz-rap during a time where gangsta rap was really dominant with Doggystle and The Chronic even they put Low End and Peoples Travels before. MM was their best and got them attention. They were a lot different than most rappers then Illmatic was similar to the rugged lyrical style of a few NY rappers (WU, BIG etc)

If I had a gun to my head, I'll prolly chose OB4CL right before he pulled the trigger because I still wouldn't have an answer for this question.
 
Finally I thread worth talking about in the music forum. This is such a hard question but a good one. And on that note I'll have to push. I can literally know each and every verse on both albums. I live these two albums here. MM IMO created jazz-rap during a time where gangsta rap was really dominant with Doggystle and The Chronic even they put Low End and Peoples Travels before. MM was their best and got them attention. They were a lot different than most rappers then Illmatic was similar to the rugged lyrical style of a few NY rappers (WU, BIG etc)

If I had a gun to my head, I'll prolly chose OB4CL right before he pulled the trigger because I still wouldn't have an answer for this question.
 
Midnight Marauders or Low End Theory for me. Too many songs are just flat out better.
 
Midnight Marauders or Low End Theory for me. Too many songs are just flat out better.
 
Originally Posted by I Live In Texas

No.

Due to the fact that Tip was really corny with his lyrics.

Sucka !*+%*?
Lyrics to Go?
Midnight?
You're buggin dude

Anyways, i dont see them as very comparable, as they represent two walks of hip op. However, they are the both 1st class albums in their own respects.
 
Originally Posted by I Live In Texas

No.

Due to the fact that Tip was really corny with his lyrics.

Sucka !*+%*?
Lyrics to Go?
Midnight?
You're buggin dude

Anyways, i dont see them as very comparable, as they represent two walks of hip op. However, they are the both 1st class albums in their own respects.
 
Apples and Oranges.

You're better off comparing De La Soul is Dead to Midnight Marauders.

My-T.
 
Apples and Oranges.

You're better off comparing De La Soul is Dead to Midnight Marauders.

My-T.
 
Originally Posted by GL Rayner

Originally Posted by mossman75

IMO Midnight Marauders is the better album, its more entertaining

QFT.

And while we are on the subject, whats everyone's opinion on the better album between MM and Low End Theory
nerd.gif
.......

As you can tell with the Post I created I have to say its MM>TLET

The Low End Theory is 3rd on my list of Greatest Hip-Hop Albums, I remember the first time I heard that Album and the way it came across BLEW ME AWAY
pimp.gif
!!!
at first, I couldn't get pass "Excursions" because the song was sooo dope I didn't want to proceed to hear the rest of the Album yet since I had it on repeat
laugh.gif
!!

Butter is the one though, that Saxaphone Sample in the chorus is like the illest thing i've ever listened to !!!
but it falls short to MM because they have a few fillers on the Album IMO (What?, Skypager, Buggin' Out (at times) and MM has none
 
Originally Posted by GL Rayner

Originally Posted by mossman75

IMO Midnight Marauders is the better album, its more entertaining

QFT.

And while we are on the subject, whats everyone's opinion on the better album between MM and Low End Theory
nerd.gif
.......

As you can tell with the Post I created I have to say its MM>TLET

The Low End Theory is 3rd on my list of Greatest Hip-Hop Albums, I remember the first time I heard that Album and the way it came across BLEW ME AWAY
pimp.gif
!!!
at first, I couldn't get pass "Excursions" because the song was sooo dope I didn't want to proceed to hear the rest of the Album yet since I had it on repeat
laugh.gif
!!

Butter is the one though, that Saxaphone Sample in the chorus is like the illest thing i've ever listened to !!!
but it falls short to MM because they have a few fillers on the Album IMO (What?, Skypager, Buggin' Out (at times) and MM has none
 
Great thread....

Musically MM is superior but overall importance and hip-hop brilliance goes to Illmatic.

But someone was right when they said it's one of the 4 or 5 who can be in that conversation.
 
Back
Top Bottom