He and I were basically saying the same thing. Bottom line, he was buying a pair from GOAT at X price. That's all that matters. Think of it his way, your purchase/sell isn't tied to a specific buyer/seller. When the shoes come in, they toss the seller's paperwork after they are authenticated. They go into a pile with hundreds of pairs of the same shoe. As a buyer, I'll get one of those pairs. Doesn't mean I'll get the exact one that I clicked buy on.
I think in probably 99% of the cases, you’re in fact receiving the exact pair you purchase via the app. I’m not sure if you noticed, but when you buy your shoes, it will let you know when they’re on their way to the facility, when they received them, or whether your pair passed or failed authentification (a passed pair will be in the form of “they’re on their way). I honestly couldn’t tell you time it would be otherwise.
A few times I’ve had pics sent from both GOAT and StockX on the condition of shoes and whether they were acceptable to me. One difference between the two is GOAT will ask the seller how much they’re willing to take off the price from 5% to I believe up to 20%. If the buyer declines, GOAT will ask you whether you want your pair shipped back or put on consignment. Additionally, GOAT will let sell used shoes, but StockX does not. On occasion, GOAT will sell pairs the company has as well. Outside of that, it’s Seller A shipping GOAT/StockX to buyer A. It’s not a first in, first out type of transaction. They’re simply a middle man that verifies authenticity/they’re up to snuff between 2 customers.
To answer the comment about the poor sap waiting. If you so happened to have purchased a pair of from a deadbeat, they you’re also the poor sap that gets refunded; it’s not random.
Think of it like this. If they sold a pair of Yeezys and shipped them off to a customer and the pair they get it is fake, that means StockX or GOAT would be upside down and would be taking it in the pants. You’d be charged a lot more than 15% for the inconvenience. You’d be on the hook for entire amount of the purchase and probably 15% for their inconvenience. Even if you’re paid through StockX and they fail, they get their money back and they send that particular pair back to the seller. Hope that makes sense.
From GOAT:
“How does it work?
Sellers list their sneakers for sale on GOAT, while buyers peruse over 75,000 sneakers on the website, iPhone and Android apps. If you make a purchase, sellers are required to ship their sneakers to us for verification first and once they’re authenticated, we’ll ship them to you. If we find they are replicas or they are not as described, we’ll notify you and offer a full refund.”