there's 5 top pairs, Hanons, Packers, Footpatrols, HALs and Afews (I know the materials are rubbish but they look so good on foot?
3 solid pairs - Mitas, Baits and Concepts
and 3 poor pairs - the Titolos, Colettes and Atmos...
I think overall it's been a really good year with some fantastic pairs, the only thing that's let the event down is the hype and reselling but that's the sign of the times and not particularly Asics fault
Titolos DO NOT belong in the same category with the colettes and atmos. My pair gets a lot of wears...I love my "bred" colorways (I'm from chi originally so bulls and blackhawks). Clean shoe with nice details and the materials slay a lot of kicks you have listed higher including packer and afew. My list after having every pair in hand but the hanon:
1. Hanon (gorgeous, still depressed over missing)
2. Mita (materials and execution were bomb)
3. Concepts (beautiful classic east coast colorway)
4. Titolo (UNDERRATED)
5. Bait (Thought they were trash, but in hand they're really different for a black shoe)
6. HAL (just too many mint kicks, not very versatile)
7. Packer (great colorway. average materials)
8. Foot Patrol (boring to me. olive is a drab color)
9. Afew (GR quality materials)
10. Atmos (nurses gotta flex too)
11. Kith (those what the are completely unmatching. The general population will just think you are confused. they should have had 2 shoes with similar patchwork, just mixed up somewhat)
12. Colette (crease factory. polka dots. 200 price point. garbage materials)