|A-Man|
formerly atgd7154xbbxmz
- 17,340
- 2,011
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2011
To me I saw Shane as an obsessed savage going through psychosis. Naivete and being realistic is one thing but he just seems too quick to jump in to that no rules no civility mode no matter what. Son was just an outright egoist and not being smart enough to hide it.Originally Posted by iYen
Originally Posted by ATGD7154xBBxMZ
How are Shane, Itatchi, Scar, and Magneto anti-heroes? Especially Shane and Magneto.
Shane: He wants what's best for the group but is realistic about his approach. Whereas Rick is always trying to save somebody.
Itachi: Made the ultimate sacrafice to prevent the village from being destroyed.Spoiler [+]When the secret comes out that Shane killed Otis, Rick was like I ain't even mad. That to me shows that Rick and Shane's heroic qualities are very similar. The main difference is that Shane isn't as naive as Rick.
Scar: At the end of fmab, it's implied that he becomes just like that other Ishvalan.
Magneto: Rather than wanting to coexist with the humans, he would rather have mutants rule.
Itachi to me was just a lame soldier taking orders. The ultimate sacrifice can't be being seen as a crazy mass murderer and traitor because the truth of the matter is you were ordered to be a mass murderer to save the village. The way his actions were explained it would make more sense if they had lied to him about why he had to kill his own clan. IMO Kishi just did not do a good job.
Oh well in the end yeah, maybe, but throughout the story Scar's just killing for revenge in both versions.
Magneto through the various stories in the X-Men has evolved in to Hitler and that isn't just some nazi argument I'm throwing out there son was so twisted that you could say he was the direct cause for mutants being in the situation they are in now.
Jus' sayin'