yeah true opinions vary. I honestly can't imagine liking OTs the most of the 4 though. maybe if you'd only seen them in pictures, but yea in real life they are a very boring dull/dingy brown colour, not the nice rich colour in pics. and yeah the quality looks cheap. hard to wear too, always felt they ruined my outfit because I hate the colour.
Pirate Blacks are easily the best for me. I wear mine all the time. love the colours and the contrast of the red stretched heel tab and the effectiveness of the subtle flecks on the black. I'd like a pair if Turtledoves just because they're special for being OG. but I have no interest in moonrocks or another pair of tans, hope they're never rereleased.
I own TB 750s and GITD. GITD is considerably better than the TB in looks and quality. in surprised many people aren't really feeling them, to me they are amazing.