ST. LOUIS -- Mick Kelleher's first year in professional baseball was in 1969, and he says he had never seen before what he saw Monday: a crowd give a standing ovation to a catcher for throwing out a runner. But this is St. Louis and the catcher is Yadier Molina, and when he gunned down Brett Gardner in the eighth inning -- zipping a throw that Jhonny Peralta caught and dropped down on Gardner's left shoulder -- the fans all rose as one and chanted his first name.
"We've seen some pretty good catchers the last 40 to 50 years," said Kelleher, the first-base coach for the Yankees and a former Cardinal. "That was tremendous. I even get excited about something like that. Great baseball fans, great baseball city."
And an even greater catcher. Gardner was the 23rd baserunner who had attempted to steal a base against Molina this season, and the 13th to get thrown out. But when Jacoby Ellsbury drew a walk against Randy Choate to open the top of the 12th inning, with the score tied 3-3, Ellsbury figured he would try to steal at some point. The game situation dictated that he at least try, and besides, there is a difference between Ellsbury and most others who try to steal bases, including some faster than he is.
Molina "basically shuts the running game down," Kelleher said. "There are only a few guys who can even run on him … [But] Ellsbury is a tremendous base stealer. He has a knack, with a real sense of timing. It's incredible. He's as good as I've seen, except for maybe Lou Brock or Rickey Henderson, as far as the feel, the knack. As good as Gardy is, he doesn't have the same knack."
Last year, Ellsbury attempted 63 stolen bases in the regular season and postseason and was thrown out just five times. He has led the American League in steals in three different seasons at a success rate of 84 percent. Among players with at least 250 steals in their careers, that is the third highest of all time; only Tim Raines and Eric Davis are better.
Ellsbury watches video of pitchers to get some sense of their pickoff moves and their habits, like how many times they throw to first base, and Ellsbury has been amazed, once he reaches first base, by how often pitchers will alter their habits. Justin Verlander, he recalled, had rarely thrown to first base leading up to the playoffs, and yet when Ellsbury reached, Verlander kept firing over, trying to catch him, trying to keep him close.
Because Ellsbury had played against the Cardinals in last year's World Series, he had some sense of Choate's move to first base even before he reviewed his recent work. Choate had allowed 15 stolen bases in his entire career, a span of 559 games, before Ellsbury took his lead with Brian McCann at the plate. So in other words, Ellsbury was faced with a pitcher who doesn't allow steals working to one of the best-throwing catchers of all time. Choate threw to first, repeatedly, with Ellsbury stepping back to first. "I was looking to go," Ellsbury said. "It was a matter of when."
When Ellsbury gets to first base, he carries with him all of his preparation, the scouting reports and his video work. But like a hitter adjusting to a pitcher's stuff in a given at-bat, Ellsbury will alter his timing according to what he sees in that moment, and he had something on Choate. He saw something. Kelleher wouldn't detail the conversation he had with Ellsbury in between pitches of McCann's at-bat -- there are still two games remaining in this series, and any information the Yankees have gleaned may be used over the next 48 hours -- but he said he knew that Ellsbury would run on the 0-2 pitch.
Ellsbury got a nice break, Molina whipped a throw to second and the tag on Ellsbury was high and very close. Cardinals manager Mike Matheny immediately came out of the dugout to challenge, and from second base, Ellsbury watched the Cardinals dugout scramble to get a read on the replay. Matheny decided to challenge, which made sense, on a crucial play in the 12th inning. Ellsbury thought he was safe. "But any time you get that replay, you never know," he said.
Larry Vanover, the crew chief and the umpire who had the call at second base, took off his headset and flattened his hands in the air: safe.
The play changed the whole inning, as Brendan Ryan noted later. With Ellsbury at second and nobody out, McCann's mission was to pull a ball to the right side, and Choate, having to pitch with even more precision, bounced a pitch off McCann's backside. Yangervis Solarte bunted the runners to second and third, and with Ichiro at the plate and Brian Roberts on deck, Mike Matheny decided to intentionally walk Ichiro -- then looked at Choate and clapped his hands assertively, letting him know that he was leaving Choate in the game to get Roberts.
But Roberts lashed a single to left field and Ellsbury trotted home with the first of three decisive runs, and the Yankees went on to close out another extra-inning victory.
"He wanted to make a difference there," Ryan said. And Ellsbury did.
• Roberts rescued the Yankees, writes Mark Feinsand. Brett Gardner stole one from Molina, writes Bob Klapisch.
• Hyun-Jin Ryu nearly outdid Josh Beckett a day after Beckett's no-hitter, coming within six outs of a perfect game. From ESPN Stats & Information, how Ryu came close:
A. Threw 59.0 percent of his pitches in the strike zone, the second-highest rate in any start in his career.
B. Reds hitters were 2-for-17 in at-bats ending with a pitch in the strike zone.
C. Hitters were 0-for-11 with four strikeouts in at-bats ending with his fastball.
• Meanwhile, A.J. Ellis was placed on the disabled list after getting hurt during the no-hitter celebration.
Olney Signed Ball
Buster Olney/ESPN
Geddy Lee's autographed baseball.
• Rip Rowan is the equipment manager of the St. Louis Cardinals, and a friend asked him to get Derek Jeter and Ichiro Suzuki to sign a ball.
Except it's not just any baseball. This one contains the names of almost all of those who accumulated 3,000 hits in their careers. Pete Rose signed the ball, and so did Ty Cobb, and Stan Musial and Roberto Clemente and Carl Yastrzemski, George Brett, Hank Aaron, etc., etc. The only names that Derrick Goold and I couldn't find on the ball were those of Honus Wagner and Cap Anson.
The friend who asked Rip for a favor? Geddy Lee, the front man for the Hall of Fame band Rush, who is a huge baseball fan.
Around the league
• Within the context of 2014, Yordano Ventura seems like the perfect candidate for an elbow injury: He's really good, and he throws really hard. And now he has an elbow injury, as Andy McCullough writes, although Ned Yost says he's not concerned that this injury involves the ligament.
Really, it's incredible how often this has happened this year.
• Mets prospect Noah Syndergaard also has an elbow injury, as Tim Rohan writes.
• Cliff Lee has not been given clearance to resume throwing.
• The Rockies were shut down on the road, again, as Kyle Kendrick pitched a gem. These are the same old Rockies on this trip, writes Patrick Saunders.
The gap between their home and road run production is so stark that it's as though they are completely different teams.
Colorado at home: .952 OPS, 6.7 runs per game, an MLB-best 162 runs
The Rockies on the road: .687 OPS, 3.6 runs per games, 100 runs (17th best).
• There might be better relievers than Dellin Betances right now, but there is nobody else like him. The Yankees right-hander's fastball averages 95.5 mph, and Monday against the Cardinals, he was throwing up to 98 mph. But he throws his primary secondary pitch, his spike curveball, more than he throws his fastball -- 45.5 percent of the time, according to FanGraphs -- and the difference in average velocity is a staggering 13 mph. The disparity is so great that the hitters -- who must anticipate a fastball that good in order to keep up with it -- must essentially guess which pitch he's going to throw.
When Allen Craig batted against Betances on Monday, for example, he had seen other hitters get the curveball, so he looked for the curve. But when Craig got fastballs, all he could do was ward them off to the right side.
Betances has faced 113 batters this season and struck out 51 of those, with just nine walks, and because hitters are stuck in between, they've mustered a .221 slugging percentage against him.
From the Elias Sports Bureau: Betances got 50 strikeouts in 28 2/3 innings, the fewest needed to accumulate 50 strikeouts in a season by a Yankees pitcher in franchise history. The previous record was 31 1/3 innings pitched by Ron Davis in 1981, which was later matched by David Robertson in 2011.
• The Mets fired their hitting coach, Dave Hudgens, who said he believes that the booing at home is a problem. From Adam Rubin's story:
"I really just think guys tried too hard at home," Hudgens told MLB.com after his firing. "I think the fans are really tough on the guys at home. How can you boo Curtis Granderson? They have no idea how hard this guy works and how he goes about doing his business, doing his job. He gets off to a slow start and they're booing him? Come on. It’s tougher at home to play than it is on the road, there's no doubt about it. And they're trying really hard at home.
"You can see it in the statistics. The fly-ball rates went up, the swing-and-miss rates went up at home. I think we were first in the league in runs scored on the road, so I think guys were relaxed on the road. They could just go out and play the game, don’t worry about anything. Then at home, they’re trying to do so much. I’ve never seen that work out -- especially young players trying to do more than they should be doing. When you look at the numbers inside the numbers, and you see exit velocity rates going down at home, you see fly ball rates going up, you see swing-and-miss rates going up, you see chase rates going up a little bit -- although we’re best in the league in not chasing pitches out of the zone -- I think those things, it just means guys trying to do too much, trying too hard."
Hudgens also had some thoughts about Keith Hernandez's commentary on the Mets' broadcasts. From Marc Carig's story:
Hudgens, who joined the Mets in 2011, defended the team's patient hitting approach, which has been bashed by broadcaster Keith Hernandez.
"The naysayers, the guys who disapprove of us, the guys who I listen to on TV all the time, those guys that know everything about the game, I'm just amazed at it," Hudgens said.
"What's wrong with getting a good pitch to hit? Somebody, please punch a hole in that for me. I just shake my head at the old-school guys that have it all figured out. Go up there and swing the bat. Well, what do you want to swing at? It just confounds me. It's just hilarious, really.
"That's one thing. I'm glad I don't have to listen to those guys anymore."
• The Blue Jays are the first AL East team to 30 wins, and they are on a serious roll.
• Jeff Samardzija finally got his first win of the season.
• The Red Sox ended their losing streak, as Peter Abraham writes. Ben Cherington says they haven't performed.
• The Tigers got smacked around again.
Dings and dents
Ryan Zimmerman
Chuck Myers/MCT/Getty Images
Nationals third baseman Ryan Zimmerman hopes to be back soon from a thumb injury.
1. Ryan Zimmerman got clearance to hit and throw.
2. Mark Teixeira was scratched from the lineup Monday with tightness in his wrist.
3. Mat Latos can't wait to get back.
4. The Indians are dealing with some injuries.
5. Jim Henderson had a setback, as Todd Rosiak writes.
6. Brandon Guyer suffered a broken thumb.
7. Within this notebook, there is word that Mark Trumbo is no longer wearing a boot.
8. Hector Sanchez admits that he's worried about blows to the head.
Moves, deals and decisions
1. The Red Sox need to let Clay Buchholz sit, writes Nick Cafardo. There are some rumblings within the Red Sox organization to that end, that Buchholz will be at least temporarily moved out of his role.
2. Randy Wolf is going to get another start.
3. Matt Kemp was benched for the fourth consecutive game.
Monday's games
1. The Pirates rallied against Jose Valverde, as Travis Sawchik writes.
2. Nick Hundley helped the Orioles, writes Dan Connolly.
3. Jose Quintana got a nice cushion.
4. Ervin Santana blew a big lead.
5. A.J. Pollock came up big.
6. Chris Young dominates in Safeco Field, as Bob Dutton writes.
NL West
• Somebody stole Hunter Pence's scooter.
• Yasiel Puig is the best right fielder in baseball, says Don Mattingly.
• Tommy Medica is looking for more playing time, writes Jeff Sanders.
NL Central
• Don't expect the Pirates to make an emotional decision to keep hometown kid Neil Walker, writes Ron Cook.
• Michael Wacha threw the ball well.
• The Reds avoided being no-hit.
• Manny Ramirez has high-impact potential, says Theo Epstein.
The general reaction to the hiring around MLB, in a word: shock.
• K-Rod blew another save chance.
NL East
• Giancarlo Stanton hit another monster homer Monday, a 447-foot shot in the third inning at Washington, his MLB-leading sixth homer of at least 440 feet this season. His average home run in 2014 has been 431 feet, 34 feet longer than the MLB average.
Stanton's 15th homer helped the Marlins win Monday, as Manny Navarro writes.
• Justin Upton likes hitting at home, writes Carroll Rogers.
AL West
• Oakland had a home run party and the Tigers were invited.
• For Tyler Skaggs, progress.
• George Springer had a huge game. ESPN Research monster Justin Havens sent out this list late last night:
In addition to becoming the first Astros player to have four hits, five runs, three RBIs and a home run, he joined an impressive list of AL outfielders to do so:
AL outfielders since 1950
Monday, George Springer, Astros*
1998, Juan Encarnacion, Tigers
1996, Ken Griffey Jr., Mariners*
1994, Tim Raines, White Sox
1986, Joe Carter, Indians
1972, Bobby Murcer, Yankees
1959, Rocky Colavito, Indians*
1955, Minnie Minoso, White Sox
*Did not record an out
• Rougned Odor might be the Rangers' second baseman of the future.
• Ron Washington is nearing a managerial mark.
• Lloyd McClendon says he likes what he sees from the Mariners so far, writes Ryan Divish.
AL Central
• Detroit's offensive weak spots are starting to show, writes Shawn Windsor.
• A Royals prospect is starting to put it together.
• Lonnie Chisenhall is gaining confidence against left-handers, writes Marla Ridenour.
• The Twins' desperation is not a good thing for Aaron Hicks, writes Chip Scoggins.
• Minnesota has a dubious number attached to it.
AL East
• Chase Whitley continues to help the Yankees as they struggle for depth in their rotation; he pitched into the sixth inning here Monday. Whitley was a 15th-round pick, and I asked Yankees scouting director Damon Oppenheimer about the background of how they picked out Whitley.
"Our area scout DJ Svihlik took our National Crosschecker Kendall Carter to see a starter against Troy University. There were a bunch of teams there to see the guy (don't remember his name); after he finished and was out of the game, all of the teams left and DJ asked the Troy coach if he could please put Chase in for an inning or more so his cross checker could see him. The coach did and our guys saw 90-to-91 mph with good change up and a competitor. We were able to draft him lower just because DJ knew the competition.
"Chase has worked hard and refined his stuff and control. Quality competitor."
• Dan Shaughnessy wants to debunk some myths about the 2014 Sox.
• Jonathan Schoop hit two homers Monday and wanted more.
Lastly
• Vin Scully is missing a couple of games.
• Ozzie Smith helped give the Cardinals' goodbye to Derek Jeter.
• The '64 Cardinals got the band back together.
• Vanderbilt has Xavier in the NCAA tournament.
And today will be better than yesterday.